Alabama

“Great movie! You have produced a collection of stories that so many of us around the country share. This movie needs to be in every classroom and library in America.”
26-year-old male, Asian, Muslim, American citizen

Alaska

Arizona

“I went to the Phoenix premiere. It was incredible. It moved me to tears. I had the pleasure of meeting Valarie. She’s a great person. She is the voice of many. Her voice resonates for us all through her documentary. I’m proud of what she’s done.”

Irma Tsosiei
Lab Technician
34-year-old female, Native American Indian,
Phoenix

“I think that the film turned out amazing over all. The whole Divided We Fall crew did a great job putting together the stories nationwide. Hopefully we can spread the word more about different cultures and get people to understand more about the differences among people! I think Valarie and Sharat have taken off on a good start on spreading the word! Good Job!! We’re hoping to see you guys back in AZ soon!”

Chandni Sodhi
 (niece of Balbir Singh Sodhi),
 18-year-old female, Sikh, American citizen, 
Mesa

California

Berkeley

“Thank you for making this wonderful film. You truly seized an historical moment and collected stories that needed to be recorded. You provided a fair and passionate picture (not an easy feat!) of post-9/11 America. Thank you for jump-starting and contribution to a dialogue that desperately needs to take place.”
26-year-old male, White, American citizen, 
Berkeley

“I thought the movie was really amazing and very moving. I agree with the idea of bringing tissues! I hope many more people get the opportunity to see this movie, I simply was not aware of the severity and the stories of the people really hit close.

I think maybe if the guy from the train station who yelled ‘go home’ had a chance to watch this movie, it would change his attitude.”
21-year-old female, White, American/Danish citizenship

“A really warm, open, and refreshingly non-didactic documentary about a really important issue post-9/11 that I was hardly aware of to the degree I feel I am now. Thank you for being so courageous!”
Tiffany
, 24-year-old female, White, American citizen

“My name is Devin Fitzpatrick, and I am very happy to see a fellow student of religious studies working so hard to affect the world. I am a philosophy/religious studies double major here at Cal, and I was deeply moved by your film. As I have a Japanese stepmother and half-sister, I have perhaps been confronted by questions of racial identity more often than my fellow upper-middle class Caucasians; still, I feel almost presumptuous that I was moved to tears by your message. But it is not just that your actions personally inspire me and my belief that my studies can truly be used to help others — I am reminded of my mother Joan who passed on three years ago, and while she lived was the Brotman Professor of Law at the University of Washington. She was a member of Amnesty International, and taught international law, human rights law, immigration law, and women’s rights. I don’t usually make a point of my great pride in her — there is a family tragedy associated with her death, so despite her great influence on me, I do not often bring her up — but I feel I was personally moved because your movie reminded me of her.

I just remember how outraged she was at the Sikh death in Arizona… I heard of it before any of my friends, and I didn’t even know what a Sikh was. She probably didn’t either. But her passion for human justice spurred her on all the same…

I hope to tie together ethics and what we find meaningful in a reasonable manner, in a message that anyone can understand, so that no one will be motivated by fear, and continue to commit the crimes your film depicts. My own talents are modest compared to my mother’s, and being young my ambitions are obviously far too wide, sweeping, but still — I am reminded by how one individual’s false beliefs can hurt so many, and how a few wise words from a passionate speaker might have changed this.

I am reminded of my own mission, and my commitment to constantly intellectually challenging myself and others, and keeping a dialogue open — so that we can continue to ask, like you say, what it means to be American — and what it means to be united as humans as well. And if a guy like me can be inspired by a story about Sikhs, well… maybe I’m already on to something.

Thank you for your hard work. Thank you very much.
Devin Fitzpatrick
,20-year-old male, White, American citizen

“You are a rockstar. Thank so much for putting this film together. It was beautifully done. The commentary and analysis were insightful and thought-provoking. I am not Sikh, but have experienced several bouts of discrimination. I feel we need to draw on a shared sense of community in order to fight the good fight. Thank you for bringing us a step closer…”
25-year-old female, Indian-American

“Thank you, thank you, THANK YOU! What a tremendous gift. Please keep telling these stories and more and let us know how we can help spread the word!”
28-year-old female, White, Christian, American citizen

“Thank you, Valarie, for a life-changing film. I appreciate your inclusion of the effects on children. As an Asian-American who grew up in the Midwest, it touched that experience as a non-white child in the U.S. Keep up the wonderful work.”
Desuah Yu
37-year-old female, Chinese-American, Christian, American citizen

“This was an amazing film that moved me to tears even though I normally don’t cry for movies. Thank you.

Although this film came from a Sikh perspective, it did shine light on issues that need to be faced. Coming from a Muslim family I have a very Muslim name and although I have not been the victim of hate violence, I have experienced prejudice in recent years, from airports to classmates to even a boyfriend. Prejudice and hate are still everywhere and these stories need to be told. Thank you for letting voices be heard. You have inspired me to look for more in my life and make a change. Thank you.”
Shahyodhi Ahmed
18-year-old female, biracial: Mexican/Pakistani, raised Muslim, American citizen

“Thank you for including relevant positive portrayals of Christians in addition to the necessary and important footage of Christians being bigots.

Also, thanks for including the names of those 19 killed (on the map at the end). I noticed that there were two Arab Christians killed, and I’m so glad you’re publicizing this wrongful persecution of Sikhs and other groups (Hindus, Muslims, Christians, etc). As you probably know, Arab and Palestinian Christians have been terribly persecuted (directly and indirectly) by white American Christians, and you’ve done a great job of exposing this type of persecution of many groups!”
27-year-old male, Caucasian (Scandinavian-American), Christian (Lutheran), American citizen

“This film has a profound impact on not only the Sikh community but also people of other religious backgrounds. I have never been so proud to be a Sikh. We should stand tall. I recommend this movie to anyone, of all ages and background. I’d never have the guts to make this bold movie and create a great documentary, however after 9/11 I wrote many letters that were published in local newspapers — these letters reflected my thoughts and feelings regarding hate crimes. I’m so glad to have had this opportunity to see the film.”
21-year-old female, Sikh, American citizen

“Way to keep it real.”
22-year-old female, white, American citizen

“I cried and cried throughout the film, so aside from all the compliments you get, I want to say that you are a very strong person to go through the journey and stay strong as you heard all the stories first hand. If I had a hat, I would definitely say ‘hats off to you.’”
Rubal, 
19-year-old female, Indian/Punjabi, Sikh, American citizen

“I liked how you let the stories of the interviewees speak for themselves. It is a beautiful, moving, and necessary film. I admire everyone involved with it.”
22-year-old female, South Asian (Indian), Hindu, American citizen

“Thank you for making this amazing film. Your insights and those from others in your film need to be spread widely. Thank you for the historical footage and information. It was hard to see the footage again and again. You are a rock star with amazing heart and love. Even if you don’t get the widely circulated as you may dream of and what it merits know that the lives that you have touched has created more love and peace in this crazy world filled with so much fear and hatred.’”
41-year-old female, African American

“This was a very well made film, and it was full of many strong and important messages. I was particularly glad that you drew connections with historical events and hate crimes. I also appreciated the way you pointed out the cycle of violence — especially state violence in war and death penalty.”
27-year-old male, white, atheist, American citizen

“This took me back to post-9/11 and when I felt scared for my family, my nephew who looks Arab and attended a school and a lot of international kids and was threatened by a bomb. When a lot of us felt scared as Americans and scared as the other. Thank you for this film and the feeling of solidarity it gave.”
27-year-old female, Pakistani, Muslim, American citizen

“I enjoyed the film, it has a compelling message that we all have helped built this country. This film has help me greatly understand the plight of how difficult it can be to accept those that are different from us. This film can enhance the power of diversity not just the idea.”
male, Chicano, Catholic, American citizen

“Valarie,

 this was a very touching movie. I wish more people in our community would become activists, and help educate the community.

 Keep up the good work and hope to see you at the movies.”
37-year-old male, Indian, Sikh, American citizen

“God bless you for putting forth such a great amount of effort and energy to produce this film. It got to my heart and I’ll be honest and admit that I shed tears. Thank you!”
19-year-old male, Punjabi, Sikh, American citizen

“For me Sikhs have been my community and every Sikh I see as a brother or sister, this reminds me that I have siblings (family) in many other communities as well.”
24-year-old female, Punjabi, Sikh, American citizen

“Excellent film, as a Sikh I could relate to what was going on with the families of the victims. I get a vibe that there should be solidarity between religions and different ethnicities.”
19-year-old male, Sikh, American citizen

“This is a beautiful film that deserves a wider audience. I was very inspired by the stories conveyed, and appreciate all the emotion shared. I wish you all the best with the film and will share what I learned with friends and family.”
24-year-old male, Punjabi/Irish/German/Scottish, Muslim, American citizen

“Thank you. I am so, so happy I decided to come tonight to see this amazing film. For five years America has not seen this side of the story in the media at the level it deserves. Though I thought it would have a certain ‘angle’ or slant, the bottom line was that we are all people, so thank you.”
18-year-old female, White, American citizen

“Absolutely great movie. Please try to have this film premiere on public television.”
20-year-old male, Punjabi/Indian, Sikh, American citizen

“I think that this was an awesome movie! It taught me so much!”
14-year-old female, Indian, Sikh, American citizen

“The film was very powerful and had an excellent dramatic through line.”
27-year-old male, White, American citizen

“This was a great documentary. I feel so many Americans can learn from this. If there is a way to make a shorter, edited version that can be shown in classrooms, I think this film can educate a lot of people.”
20-year-old female, Indian, Hindu, American citizen

“Amazing new perspective, and understanding of acts of hate I wasn’t aware of. Please continue to share this film with anyone who will see it.”
24-year-old male, Scottish/English, Lutheran (Christian), American citizen

“I’m grateful someone made this film. It’s fresh and represents the Sikh community accurately.”
21-year-old female, Indian, Sikh, American citizen

“Beautiful and moving. Amazing film.”
29-year-old female, Indian, Muslim, American citizen

“It was a really really good movie. I sincerely want to thank you for making this movie. As a young individual, the actions that you take are rather inspiring for fellow kids such as me. Continue with this and other projects. Good luck with the future and everything.”
18-year-old male, Indian, Sikh, American citizen

“Thank you for making this film! Moving and touching! Terrific job! Opened my eyes to how much ignorance and discrimination still exists in our country. I admire your bravery and determination. Thank you!”
21-year-old female, White/Filipino, Catholic, American citizen

“I can’t deny that I initially had an idea what the turban represented. Luckily for me, I got paired with a Sikh roommate to enlighten me on the history and the meaning behind it. I’d just like to say that just like you, others in your community are also trying to spread awareness, and people everywhere support your cause.”
20-year-old male, Korean, American citizen

“This is a very important film. I hope that this can be widely viewed by the people who hold racist perspectives. The film also shows how alive and real racist hate is in America and you have memorialized an important and real problem.”
25-year-old male, White, American citizen

“Wonderful. Proof that good can be done, even in times of such sorrow. Thank you.”
20-year-old female, White, American citizen

“Congratulations! On following a dream and telling a story through such a powerful medium. I especially appreciated the beginning showing the history of your family history — it shows a side of immigration that is often not told. The film makes a person think about that experience of being an immigrant American.

Have you considered showing clips in schools? Facism is a learned experience — maybe showing the film can deconstruct that experience.

 Thank you for sharing your thoughts and experiences. Thank you for telling the story of a community… of communities.”
32-year-old female, Indian/African-American, Hindu, American citizen

“The film is amazing and I hope distributions expands to the educational curriculum and the wider film circuit… so many Americans need it.”
Jyana, 
38-year-old female, Caucasian, American citizen

“This film is incredibly profound; it is one of the most important films made since 9/11. It was deeply personal for me and I hope that everyone gets a chance to see it. Thank you!”
20-year-old female, Punjabi Sikh, Sikh, American citizen

“I was very touched by this film. Thank you for your hard work and dedication to showing the truth.”
21-year-old female, Indian-American, Hindu, American citizen

“I think you did an exceptional job not moving into a message of ‘we aren’t Muslim… we are Sikh’ and bring the struggle together through education. Thanks!”
22-year-old male, Muslim, American citizen

“Fantastically thoughtful film — I wish everyone could see it.”
26-year-old female, Indian, Hindu, American citizen

“I was excited to see a film represent the aftermath of 9/11 in a manner which wasn’t portrayed before. After 9/11 I witnessed the bigotry first hand and laughed when I saw the news every day because the hatred and violence that was prevalent was ignored on the news. All I would hear was that everyone was together and one. But I didn’t see the other side, which you showed in your film.”
21-year-old male, Punjabi, Sikh, American citizen

“A deeply moving film that should be screened widely. I am a documentary filmmaker academic from India and would love to have a copy of this film to screen back home.”
Anjah Monteiro, 
51-year-old female, Indian citizen, 
Berkeley

Clovis

“I can very well identify with this film since I was born in one of the WWII Japanese internment ‘concentration’ camps — mine being on the Gila River Indian Reservation in Arizona. My parents told me stories of what had happened — much of what was notlearned written in our history books growing up in this country.

 Thank you! These stories need to be told. If these lessons are not learned, then they can and will be repeated… due to ignorance. I enjoyed the film. Well done.”
62-year-old male, Japanese-American, nature religion, American citizen

“This was a wonderful documentary. I can’t wait to see it in the theaters. The world needs to see this film.”
40-year-old female, Caucasian, Christian, American citizen

“Thank you for making this film. It is so important for Americans to see it. You and your crew are heroes, American heroes.

I was reluctant to come because of being biased. Thinking it wouldn’t have the message it gave because you were from Clovis. I think of Clovis of being redneck. Thank you for giving me a different perspective. Bless you.”
52-year-old female, Hispanic, Catholic, American citizen

“Being a Japanese-American, I realize after seeing the film, that I should have tried to learn more about what happened to the Sikh community after 9/11. In the future I will try to be more proactive in my own education and advocacy for this community.”
48-year-old female, Japanese, Christian, American citizen

“Imagine how influential this documentary may be if the 2 hours I’d just experienced changed the way I’ve been thinking about civil rights for the past 15 years. Being a citizen born with black hair and a certain skin color, I felt the film truly bought out the truth in the events of our time. The prejudice, racism, discrimination… Valarie’s story became my story. I’m very grateful for her successful ‘history day’ project.”
15-year-old female, Asian, Buddhist, American citizen

“- Ignorance is harmful.
- I feel shame for the ignorance of my country.
- I felt shame in how many Christians portrayed ignorance.
- The Christian church I attend deals with graffiti weekly also.
- Anyone attacked is wrong — I so agree with this.
- Outstanding film – so real.
- Responsibility of the individual in the machine – profound.”
45-year-old female, white/Caucasian, Christian, American citizen

“In my high school career thus far, I have experienced amounts of prejudice due to my religious beliefs, or my lack of. I have had people attempt to convert me, people flat out telling me that I am wrong, and people insulting my opinion because of my belief. I have even had people call me Satanic. In the last two years, I have given up trying to fight these people. Now, I have begun to calmly express my beliefs when they try to give me theirs.”
16-year-old male, white, atheist, American citizen

“I was also touched by History Day. Last year, I completed a documentary which centered around Raoul Wallenberg, a man who saved over 100,000 Jews during the Holocaust. Like you, I found that his story should be spread. I have been presenting my documentary film and a speech to community groups. Your film and comments have deeply inspired me to continue this work. Like you said, you’ve took on the ultimate history day project; you are an inspiration to me. Your film touched a chord deep within me — I realized my own prejudice. Your film perfectly exposed the American spirit — both good and bad. You brought light to needed areas. And your comments came straight from the heart. They truly made the message stick. I admire you and want to thank you for doing this.”
16-year-old female, Caucasian, Catholic, American citizen

“I think you struck hard at the core.

As an African American and a social psychologist, I’ve experienced racist attitudes of many Americans during the civil rights movement and to my regret, it still continues. My experience is that of the film.”
Thomas E. Russell, Ph.D.
66-year-old male, African-American, Christian, American citizen

“Valarie and director and Sonny,

 your film is reflecting of a passionate exploration that has resulted in a mature vision. Our hope is that the film will broaden the perspective of individual folks who react with fear and then, with anger and hate.

 Especially important is the need for each of us to become more aware of our own limitations, our actions and our inactions. We live in an age of an increasing media monopoly also. I say, ‘Bravo.’”
75-year-old female, Japanese, Methodist, American citizen

“I felt many of the same. It got so bad my parents told me to just say I’m Mexican.
Thank you. It was a great experience.”
Sumeer Murshed, 
16-year-old male, Yemini/Afghan, Muslim, American citizen

“Being Latino and being in education for 41 years, I have too many stories about the injustices done to our people in the educational community. What you showed in the film and what happened to your people has happened and continues to happen to the Latino community with President Bush’s proposals to the immigration solution. Great job.”
64-year-old male, Chicano/Latino, Catholic, American citizen

“As a teacher with many Sikh, Muslim, Buddhist, Animist, Christian and other students at Clovis East, I especially value what you’ve done to help overcome ignorance, fear, bigotry, racism, and hatred, and civil rights for all.

As a teacher and pastor involved in interfaith witness with Sikhs, Muslims, Jews, Christians, Buddhists, Unitarians, and others, I welcome what you’ve done for this community.

As a father and uncle of a Hmong daughter and African-American niece and nephew, I appreciate your family’s support and love.” 57-year-old male, European-American, United Methodist Christian, American citizen
Clovis Unified School District
Clovis “I wish all of us would be more willing to stick our necks out to discover prejudices in American culture; not only for Sikhs but for all peoples. You have inspired me as a young person to look at others differently.”
18-year-old female, white, Christian, American citizen

“What an inspiration! I hope that this film goes to theaters, and eventually DVD so that I can share it with everyone I know. This is such an important film to share! Stories can change the world!”
20-year-old female, American citizen

“My name is Eli Rodolfa, and I have been moved by this. Thank you. As a Philippine born Filipino I understand how you feel.”
16-year-old male, Filipino, Catholic, American citizen

“The film was moving, educational, a pleasure to view. I definitely have a better understanding of what Sikhs and others have gone through post-9/11. I am optimistic that Americans are learning. More people are seeing, studying, and understanding people who are different from themselves.”
47-year-old male, white, Mennonite, American citizen

“Flew to Toronto 10 days after 9/11. Got on plane in Fresno. A young man of Pakistani descent sat down and I watched many eyes go to him, including mine, feeling fear and suspicion. I felt angry for having that automatic reaction. It made me more conscious of living amidst the biases.”
55-year-old female, English/Scottish/Canadian/Polish, Christian/Humanist, American citizen

“I like this film. It touch my heart.

For me, I always think people all are the same.

We all need love, sincere, and helping. Everyone should realize that life is short, and everyone will die from this world know matter who you are. No one can’t take anything with them when they died. All they need to do are loving each other, be nice to each other, forgive and go on in their life with smile and happiness and keep all the good thing with them when they leave from this world.”
37-year-old female, Asian, Buddhist, American citizen

“My knowledge of hate crimes against Sikhs was very limited. I only know of what the media reported. I remember the newspaper printed examples of differenet ways a turban was wrapped to eliminate fear of all who wore them.

Working at a Clovis elementary school, I did hear of teasing and hate remarks toward Sikhs (from children). It was dealt with and not tolerated.”
51-year-old female, Mexican-American, Catholic, American citizen

“Great portrayal. The media has its way of showing news which doesn’t deal with race issues, but even more chillingly brainwashes the American public. We don’t ask questions, nor are we encouraged to do so. We are a pathetically greedy society and this from a teacher of 38 years.”
64-year-old male, Caucasian, American citizen (by way of Norway and Britian)

“A wonderful educational tool. The curriculum resources are a natural next step.” 46-year-old female, Mexican, Catholic, American citizen
Clovis Unified School District
Clovis “Powerful message, especially the analogy of the cycle — 9/11 (death) — Sikh hate crime death – death of person who took Sikh’s life. Very thought-provoking! Keep up the good work!”
58-year-old female, Armenian, Christian, American citizen

“I was touched by your gracious honest open style that permeates your film.”
63-year-old male, Japanese-American, Buddhist, American citizen

“Very impressive to go from World History to natural filmmaker. Her personality really was very unchanged from her contributions way back when she was a sophomore back at Buchanan. A great way for a history teacher to spend an evening in Clovis.”
50-year-old male, Caucasian

“Thank you so very much for helping build a community of understanding, especially in Clovis.”
34-year-old female, Native American/Caucasian, Christian, American citizen

“Valarie,

 Your video does a great job in informing your audience about the Sikh community. Very interesting history and a nice tribute to your family.

 My feeling is that conservative fundamentalists, including our President, have managed to avert their gaze from basic civil liberties, so that the people has become tolerant of intolerance.

 Hopefully your video will be seen by a wider audience.

 Best of luck.”
58-year-old male, Caucasian, atheist, American citizen

“Hate crimes suffered: 
1. Rejected by Harvard 
2. Charged too much at various dining establishments 
3. Attacked by vicious dogs,”
male, Indian, Sikh, Indian American citizen

“Beautiful, powerful film. Thank you for sharing your message.”
48-year-old female, white, Catholic, American citizen

“You could feel Valarie’s compassion and she is sincere.”
48-year-old female, Hispanic, Catholic, American citizen

“Awesome, excellent and empowering movie. Great job.”
56-year-old female, white, Catholic, Irish citizen

“Remember the Sikh ice cream man in Pinedale who bravely came out the day after Mesa, AZ.”
71-year-old female, Italian-American, Catholic, American citizen

“I really enjoyed watching the film.”
14-year-old female, Hispanic/white, Christian, American citizen

Los Angeles

“I would like to thank you for making this documentary film. One of the stories like the story of the young Muslim boy really is like my story. The morning of 9/11 at the time I was in fourth grade and 9 years old. Right now I am sophomore in high school and 15 years old. That morning 9/11 I go to school and the moment I walk in my classroom I sit in my seat. The next thing you everybodies talking about it. I am sitting and these two kids come up to me and say, ‘Hey, your dad, he’s Osama bin Laden, you’re his daughter!’ And I have nothing to say, all I do is start crying and now I regret saying to my dad that I don’t like who I am. I hate who I am. Now I regret saying that to him. I was so narrow-minded so I hope good wishes and thank you!! ”
15-year-old female, Asian Indian, Sikh American citizen

“Amazing documentary! Heart-wrenching yet thought-provoking and highly pertinent in these precarious times. Thank you for bringing these issues to the forefront in these divided times!”
34-year-old male, Indian, American citizen

“When I was 13, sometime after 9/11, I had just gotten out of the mosque for Sunday school. I still had my hijab on when I went to the shopping center. My story from here isn’t original from this point — I was approached by strangers who said things to make me cry, run away, pull my hijab off — but sadly, and most of all, to feel ashamed. Shame — how, why? I don’t know, but it’s what I felt. Five years later, I’m freshman class president, the only Muslim girl in my class. Not ashamed, although a little estranged from Islam. But there are still those weird moments when people find out I’m Muslim and look shocked.”
19-year-old female, Pakistani-American, sort of Muslim, U.S. citizen

“Thank you for creating a wonderful film. My little anecdote: I love the look on people’s faces when I answer the question: ‘Where are you from?’ ‘Chicago.’ ‘Oh.’”
24-year-old male, Punjabi, Sikh, American citizen

“This film humanized the issue of hate in a universal way. It went beyond faith, race, etc.”
25-year-old female, Punjabi, Sikh, Canadian citizen

“1. Somebody spit on my face and told me go back to Iran and ride the camel.
2. What are you doing here Arbi, get our of America, **** you guy.”
70-year-old male, Sikh, American citizen (came from Punjab [India] in 1961)

“I liked the balance of seeing the wider impact of prejudice against blacks & Muslims, and the racism throughout the world. This is a part of the human condition, not just a problem in America & Americans. Also I really liked Sonny.”
55-year-old male, Scot, Hindu/Presbyterian, American citizen

“I remember learning in World History about Pastor Martin Niemoller (in WWII) and his statement that it is necessary to stand in solidarity with marginalized and terrorized and oppressed groups because it is al too easy to distance ourselves and dissociate ourselves from groups and communities identified as the other. DWF does a fantastic and very poignant job at showing, as Valarie said, a human instead of the dehumanized enemy.”
19-year-old female, API/Chinese, agnostic, former Protestant, American citizen

“Excellent job highlighting — in a country whose flag waves so proudly, and whose motto screams ‘justice for all’ — just how much injustice persists. Look forward to seeing this on the big screen!”
Seema Patel
, 28-year-old female, South Asian (Gujarati), Hindu, American citizen

“Very good film to give more education to native American and Black community, I feel we should show this film in the schools if possible.”
76-year-old male, Sikh, Indian & American citizen

“It was good! 2 thumbs upper! Make another film!”
14-year-old male, Punjabi, Sikh, American citizen

“Great video, that must have took great courage. Looking forward to another video!”
13-year-old male, Punjabi, Sikh, American

“I really liked the part about Japanese Americans because investigates really important issues that made the film more profound.”
18-year-old female, Black, agnostic

“I loved this film. Cried too while watching it. I believe it will be an eye-opener for a lot of people. Good job done.”
32-year-old male, Indian, Sikh, Indian citizen

“It was a film done very well with extensive coverage.”
30-year-old female, Indian-Sikh, Guru Granth Sahib, Indian citizen

“I guess we have to get involved in politics in order to change the American perception of our own culture. It takes a strong (humble) leader to lead mankind to equality in society. We have taken the first step (documentary), what is next?”
46-year-old male, Indian, Sikh/Mormon, Malaysian citizen

“I loved it — very thought-provoking. Here in America we Sikhs were targeted/profiled due to a mistaken identity. What the world needs to know that the one country where Sikhs are not only harassed and profiled and discriminated against is INDIA — supposed the ‘Homeland’ of the Sikhs where they were massacred in a pogrom in 1984.”
47-year-old male, Sikh, Nigerian and Indian citizen

“A great job done in bringing in issues that keep up coming again and again in the American history. We need to work very hard in bringing together all around us and spread love and practice Sikhi.”
45-year-old male, Sikh, Indian, American citizen

“I am really touched by the story. And I certainly feel that I have to keep learning about other cultures, keep seeking truh.”
19-year-old female, Chinese citizen

“Very powerful film. It’s rare to see such a real, such a unique portrayal of a people’s struggle in film. Good job.”
19-year-old male, Black, American citizen

“VERY GOOD job! The stories told the heart of the issue — as you said it’s a human issue… just loved it — great work — I know it takes 500% to do this — and you did! Congrats!”
46-year-old female, white, Hindu, American citizen


Palo Alto (Stanford)

“You’ve made a moving piece of cinema that tells a personal story and records a piece of history. Beyond all that you aspire — and will achieve — with the power of storytelling, this film will be a piece of 9-11 history in the future, something that historians can show to students to demonstrate the hate crimes that belied the official anthem of a united front against terror.”
Rob Reich, 
Professor of Political Science, Stanford University

“As a Muslim born in America, this film deeply resonated with me. After 9/11 my own father was nearly shot after someone saw his skin color, shouted racial slurs at him and pulled out a gun to shoot him. it was only the beginning of continuing discrimination that still takes place today. I hope that this movie is shown throughout America, it’s deeply important that people see what this country is truly like – a pluralistic society made up of different cultures, races and religious persuasions. I wish you the best.”
20-year-old male, Pakistani heritage, Muslim, American citizen

“Valarie,

I’ve been hearing about your journey and film project for many years and anxiously anticipated this film. I’m glad I finally got to watch it. It was such a human story and I’m sure it’ll help people understand the real issues and hopefully trigger dialogue.

I’m so proud that a young Indian Sikh woman has made such an amazing documentary. You’ve done a lot since I met you at Stanford in 2002. I learned so much from this film and I hope this can be shown to more diverse audiences. You tied in your personal story, historical events, and their incidents together well. It was great seeing Sonny’s humor in the film too. Hope to hear from you and good luck on your journey.”
Jasleen Dhillon
, 23-year-old female, Indian American, Sikh, American citizen

“This is the only way to educate the world, knowledge is power. I am behind you 110%, this happens every day, if people know, then it will stop; people will continue to beat us up if we don’t tell them. After 9/11, I was harassed, then I said to myself, it’s our fault not to educate, let people know, LET THEM KNOW!!”
Livjat Singh, 
14-year-old male, Punjabi, Sikh, American citizen

“This is the most affecting film I have ever seen. It is a tapestry of shock, pain, fear, but most of all love, warmth, forgiveness, healthy family interaction. Thank you for the gift of this film; it shows the rare gift of hope. Good luck on the success of this film!

P.S. I believe there is a useful but very unhealthy element to hate for some people. That is to say some may be benefiting from the fear [and] anger it creates. That disgusts me.”
68-year-old male, Caucasian, spiritual but no specific religion, American citizen (and not proud of it after 9/11)

“The story I loved the most was the one about the young boy who is called ‘bin Laden.’ When you return to him later he has come to terms with and can joke about the prejudice he faces. At first he sees himself as ‘bad’ or having something wrong with him. By the end, he realizes ‘lots of people look different’ and he sees the whimsical nature (from bin Laden to Saddam) of their remarks.”
23-year-old female, Black/Caribbean, American citizen

“When growing up, I experienced discrimination because of my appearance, but never to a point of violence. What is worrying is when the light-hearted ‘poking fun’ turns into cold-blooded hatred when these intolerant people grow up. In the story of the child who gets poked fun at, he responds with violence. I feel education about tolerance and accepting others should start with children; it is difficult but should be done.”
23-year-old male, Asian, Brasilian citizen

“Being non-US citizen I actually was hardly aware of the hate violence after 9/11. It was not really covered in European press. So the film was quite useful for me. Great work!!”
27-year-old male, white, Dutch citizen

“This was brilliant — thank you! One of the most profound statements was made by Rachel at the end, ‘I really wanted my prejudices to be true.’ This seems to be at the core of hate crimes and sustained prejudices — people step out to demonstrate that their beliefs are true.

How can we bring such a simple statement to light for recognition and understanding? I will look for your success in championing such a deep purpose.

 Thank you.”
Nisha,
50-year-old female, South East Asian Indian, Hindu, American citizen (lived here since 1974, born in Kolkata)

“Wow. I am honored to be part of this project in even the smallest way… Thank you for being such a respectful guardian of my story. Best of luck with everything.”
Rachael Neumann 
(one of the interviewees in the film)
, 25-year-old female, White, Jewish, American citizen

“Valarie -

I am so amazed at the depth of feeling and warmth that emanates from your documentary. If there is anything that I can do to help the project, or if there are any causes akin to this one, I would love to get involved! You are truly an inspiration, and I hope I can utilize my Stanford experience like you have! Best of luck, and God bless.”
Alyssa, 
18-year-old female, half-Indian/half-Caucasian, Catholic, American citizen

“I’m hopelessly favorably biased toward the film, so much resonates with me. Now, after the second viewing, the two voices that hit me hardest were the two young boys, Balbir Singh’s nephew and the young Muslim boy, first called Osama bin Laden, then Saddam Hussein. What struck me, while listening to them, was how labeling and violence can so powerfully shape a community, terrorize people. The other thing that got me thinking was how these deaths (I guess this isn’t a different thought, it’s the same thought but it’s got a hold of me) are communicated to so many communities so that many many can experience fear, the sense of being the ‘other.’ This is exactly what lynching did. It let the whole black South know they were at risk. Ah, there’s so much! Keep at it!”
Joseph B., 
44-year-old male, Black, atheist, American citizen

“Your film took me back in time to a very difficult yet valuable time in my life. Five years ago seems like a lifetime ago but your film brings back such vivid memories of 9/11 and what Sikhs nationwide went through. I am so proud of your film – I cried, laughed and journeyed back to fall 2001. Valarie — your film is amazing! I remember when you and your cousin (with camera in hand) started out and after seeing this film (in whole) for the first time — God blessed us with a community leader like you who has captured 9/11 with such accuracy.”
32-year-old female, Indian, Sikh, American citizen

“I liked how you let the stories of the interviewees speak for themselves. It is a beautiful, moving, and necessary film. I admire everyone involved with it.”
22-year-old female, South Asian (Indian), Hindu, American citizen

“I am from Chicago and I went back for a football game in September. There was a Caucasian man holding a sign saying that ‘America hates the Packers.’ Now, I was at a Chicago Bears game and they have a rivalry with the Packers. So we were rooting for the same team, I even had my Bears shirt on. When I said to him I hate the Packers as well, he said to me, ‘and you look like a real American, don’t you.’”
28-year-old male, Indian, Hindu, American citizen

“This film was wonderful, I really liked how you included Japanese affliction. I loved the film and it brought tears to my eyes. I think that more people need to see this, especially mainstream America. Even though I am Indian, I learned so much. Thus you need to show this film across the country. We need to see more movies like this. Thanks!!!”
31-year-old female, Indian, Hindu, American citizen

“Great film, emotionally moving, uplifting. It would be great to see you guys on Bill O’Reilly, The Colbert Report, on The Daily Show.”
27-year-old male, Chinese, American citizen

“I enjoyed the film, it has a compelling message that we all have helped built this country. This film has help me greatly understand the plight of how difficult it can be to accept those that are different from us. This film can enhance the power of diversity not just the idea.”
Male, Chicano, Catholic, American citizen

“Really informational. I would definitely tell people about movie.

Should advertise it a lot more. (Although I will give good word of mouth responses). Makes you think about many issues showed.”
18-year-old male, Indian, Sikh, American citizen

“One story that really resonated with me was the young boy who gets called ‘bin Laden’s son’ and later ‘Saddam Hussein.’ As a South Asian Muslim male, I have been targeted and called an ‘Arab’ by peers, even since before 9/11. The misperceptions that were portrayed are accurately and unfortunately nascent in much of American youth.”
19-year-old male, Bangladeshi, Muslim, American citizen

“If this movie can be sent to school districts and should be shown to all the teachers and school staff wherever it is possible through state department.”
Sarabjit K. Cheema, 
47-year-old female, Sikh, American citizen

“Amazing job — let’s work together to share this with the world. I could not be more proud of what you two have done.”
Mandeep Dhillon, 
36-year-old male, Indian, Sikh, American citizen

“Congratulations! Having lived in California during the 9/11 attacks and being part of the community (Sikh), the film was still a revelation to me on what Sikhs went through. This film motivates me to be a greater part of awareness through education.”
38-year-old female, Indian, Sikh, Canadian citizen

“It was nice how a previous dark chapter in history about the Japanese settlers was related to recent events, especially, the treatment of turbaned Sikhs.”
71-year-old male, Sikh, Canadian citizen

“Excellent documentary. I hope it will show also on PBS, besides in the movies. Hopefully you will also set it up to be shown in middle schools, high schools, colleges, as a course. There is tons of racism in this country and often it is construed by mainstream America as White and Black racism. It is SO important to show how the racism affects other people too.

Thank you so much, very powerful!”
55-year-old female, Jewish Eastern European, American and Israeli citizen

“I love that you included the quote from George W Bush in the beginning/opening clips — that wasn’t present in the film when I saw it in 2004 and I’m glad you added it. I can’t wait for the film to go HUGE in theaters soon, and I’m already telling my friends to look out for it and go see it. Your accomplishments are so amazing, and I have so much respect for you! I sincerely hope that someday we can sit down and have a conversation about our lives.”
Jenny Wolochow
, 19-year-old female, Jewish/White, Jewish, American and Canadian citizen

“It transported me back to the 9/11 event and how I felt afterwards. I was most like Rachael, and feel ashamed actually. I expect this film will help me and my view of others.”
56-year-old male, Caucasian, American citizen

“The film was terrific — fascinating and well done. There are many things about it that I like, but probably the biggest thing is that you made it. I am in awe of people who see something that should be done and just say to themselves, ‘I can do that. I can make a difference.’ And then they go out and do it. Kudos to you!”
55-year-old female, White, American citizen

“Great movie, in this era people only care about mainstream things and your movie is a rare way to reach out to people and alarm them about terrible situation that is happening around us. It is sad that in this such a modern era, people still tend to be insensitive and take things for granted.

I hope other communities will attempt to create some ways to introduce and communicate their identity, so that all the misunderstandings between us can diminish.”
25-year-old male, Asian-Chinese, Indonesian citizen

“The film was terrific — fascinating and well done. There are many things about it that I like, but probably the biggest thing is that you made it. I am in awe of people who see something that should be done and just say to themselves, ‘I can do that. I can make a difference.’ And then they go out and do it. Kudos to you!”
55-year-old female, White, American citizen

“As I was watching the film, I thought about my trip to Mesa, AZ shortly after 9/11. My sister was living there at the time and I was going to the World Series game with her. As I was going to watch the game and the great American pastime, an entire community in Mesa was in tremendous pain. I vaguely remember stories about 9/11 backlash and hate crimes at the time, but don’t remember at all how it affected the Sikh community. Your film is insightful and inspirational. Thank you and best wishes for your continued success.”
36-year-old male, Asian-American, Catholic, American citizen

“Great job, I’m wishing you the best of luck…”
26-year-old female, White, Jewish, American/Israeli citizen

“I think the movie is a great tribute to Sikhism — to the openness and generosity of this religion.”
no demographic information given

“Very good film. Touched me personally. What is the solution to the problem — the way people are perceived? How can future violence be prevented?”
Hindu, Indian citizen

“Very nicely done. Could slightly reduce the length. At some points I felt that the movie will finish. So you may likes to build it such that the end has a message of some way for non-Sikhs to do in their daily lives.”
45-year-old male, Indian, Hindu, American citizen

“I especially liked the line that went like this: ‘For us to be right, they have to be wrong.’”
24-year-old male, Indian, Sikh, German citizen

“I’m sure you’ve heard this many times, but you’ve done really is amazing. This night and the documentary are large contributions to those experiences which make me, someone at times on the brink of absolute despair and hopelessness, strong again.

There are many things…

Thank you.”
Japneet Kaur
, 17-year-old female, Indian, Sikh, Indian/American citizen

“Ignorance is rampant in America, thanks to inferior educational system and a media who is biased and motivated by money, greed and sensationalism. Not to mention our stupid government who benefits from this ignorance.

 Thank you.”
46-year-old male, Middle Eastern, Muslim, Palestinian/American citizen

Pomona

“I loved the film. I want to thank you for doing it. My main reaction to the film was gratefulness, disgust, and being utterly sick watching people behave in such a manner.”
19-year-old, Female, Caucasian, American Citizen

“I am grateful that you were able to capture these people’s stories on film and share them with others, especially the stories we would have never heard otherwise.”
19-year-old, Female, Taiwanese-Japanese/American, American Citizen

“Your film was the most powerful commentary on racism and division I’ve ever seen.”
18-year-old, Female, Caucasian, Christian, England/American Citizen

“Being an Asian-American in America, this film brought me to a sad realization that we people of color are still looked upon as the “others” and “outsiders”. I hope this film will wake the people of America up to the unfortunate realities of the misconceptions of people just because of how we look.”
18-year-old, Female, Chinese/Vietnamese, Seventh Day Adventist, American Citizen

“This film is so powerful-it challenges your own prejudices and makes you realize it’s important to support others since you could be targeted next.”
21-year-old, Female, Asian, Christian, American Citizen

“It was truly a heartfelt film, I am thankful for the opportunity to be exposed to this side of mankind.”
19-year-old, Male, Asian American, American Citizen

“If this film were shown to a large enough audience the mitigation of bigotry and stereotype would be profound. The insight and experiences of this film are part of the solution to these problems.”
18-year-old, Male, Caucasian, Jewish, American Citizen

“This movie showed an aspect of the post 9/11 world that I was unaware of, thank you for the educational function of your film.”
18-year-old, Male, White, Jewish, American Citizen

“I felt ashamed that these things had happened across this country and I had not known about them, and barely thought of them.”
19-year-old, Female, White/Syrian, Agnostic, American Citizen

“You are both (Valarie and Sonny) such beautiful people and watching your work has been an inspiring and moving experience that I will carry for the rest of my life.”
20-year-old, Female, Caucasian, Jewish, American Citizen

“Thank you for promoting love.”
19-year-old, Male, Japanese, Izunome Association, Japanese Citizen

“Throughout the entire film, through all the tears, the sights – I saw the current struggles of those considered ‘aliens.”‘
18-year-old, female, Mexican American, Spiritual, American Citizen

“Growing up in a racist household I thank you for creating this film, forum, and space to talk about it and what needs to happen.”
20-year-old, Female, Welsh, Episcopal, American Citizen

“The film was very powerful and brought things to my attention I had not considered before.”
21-year-old, Female, Caucasian, Catholic, American Citizen

“Before watching this film I hadn’t realized how widespread hatred is. Even within my own actions. This film helped me to realize my own prejudices against others.”
18-year-old, Male, Salvadorian, Agnostic, American Citizen

“I really enjoyed the film because of its bold statements and harsh realities it displayed.”
19-year-old, Male, Caucasian, Christian, American Citizen

“This movie was amazing. It really showed how awful the discrimination against Sikhs and people of darker skin color was after 9/11.”
18-year-old, Female, Indian, Sikh

“This movie was interesting. I was proud of the way it brought Sikhs to attention.”
20-year-old, Female, Indian, Sikh, American Citizen

“I don’t have any words that can encompass all of what I thought. It was a spectacular creation and I am thankful to have seen it.”
21-year-old, Female, Caucasian, American Citizen

“The film was great and prompted me to think about my actions and how I can further learn.”
19-year-old, Female, Mexican-American, Catholic, American Citizen

“Your film was the hope and perseverance of those who are subjected to others ignorance.”
21-year-old, Female, Mixed, American Citizen

“The film is a powerful reminder that 9/11 is so integral to my life and to the lives of those around me. What happened since 9/11 is a reflection of deeper issues in the US – racism, oppression, and differences in power and privilege.”
20-year-old, Female, Chinese American, American Citizen

“I think it’s great how you all have shown this process of defining and exiling the “other” because of fear. I really appreciate the juxtaposition you have shown about the tolerance in the US.”
20-year-old, Female, Taiwanese American, American Citizen

“This movie should be essential to the education of this nation’s youth.”
18-year-old, Female, Chinese, Atheist, American Citizen

Sacramento

“Before I saw this movie, I did not know the extent of the prejudice. I was aware, but not as concerned as I should have been, being of Japanese descent, hearing from my grandparents their time in the camps. When I saw the segment with the Japanese, it became all too clear how easily people can and will fall into fear. This movie has open my eyes that those who know, have a certain duty to teach, and having a connection from the past, I need to acknowledge how serious the prejudice is.”
20-year-old female, Japanese, Buddhist, American citizen

“As a Mexican American, I understand what it feels like to be discriminated against. Even before 9/11 I would have random people look at me and ask me, ‘Do you even speak American’ and for a long time as a child I thought English was the American language. But as I grew I began to realize how diverse America truly is. I would go to stores like Costco and witness white Americans be treated with ‘yes sir’ and ‘no sir’ while my parents heard ‘speak English? ok what do you want.’ I have white friends who try to understand what its like to go through racism and the best way I can tell it to them its like if someone calls you a racist redneck just because your white. After 9/11 I lost three friends because they believed Mexicans had to be stopped from coming over because ‘they’ were ‘sure’ to be the next in terrorism. I remember my mother calling aunts and uncles once a week to make sure they were ok because we looked like what people perceived as ‘terrorist.’ Thank you very much for being so brave and doing this for well America!”
Janet
,19-year-old female, Hispanic/Mexican, Catholic, American and Mexican citizen

“I as a gay male was given shivers when you mentioned the hate crime against Matthew Shephard. I have feared the similar discrimination. I was not allowed to take my boyfriend to prom. Ever since that I felt as though I needed to stand up for who I am, and to help other people. I want to show that there is more than just one race, creed, orientation, religion, in a true American. Thank you very much.”
22-year-old male, Caucasian/Native American, ritualistic pagean, American citizen

“As a white woman in America I can’t relate to personal racism and discrimination but so many of my friends go through this and I want to help so much. Sometimes people used to hate me because I was white and I’ve been called racist so many times… I just hope that minorities that get discriminated against don’t take all their hate on the white people. I am deeply sorry for all the violence that happened. I learned so much. I used to assume turban = Muslim. I was just ignorant. >_< THANK YOU : )”
18-year-old female, White, agnostic, American and British citizen

“Unreal how close to home this film was… I literally cried… I remember being scared that my dad (a turbaned Sikh) would be affected by racism/hate crime.

One statement that would be helpful for people to know… how many people cut their hair after 9/11… so many of my brothers/cousins have cut their hair in the aftermath… purely out of fear or a desire to blend in. Truly saddens me.”
28-year-old female, Sikh, American citizen

“The film was good because it talked about how Sikhs were mistreated.”
12-year-old female Indian, Sikh, American citizen

“
Divided We Fall has truely represented the hideousness of hate, but also the limitless hope of the human spirit right here in America.”
Sarah D’Souza, 
Engineering Student
, 25-year-old female Pakistani/Caucasian, Catholic, American citizen

“Hey… my name is Hempreet. I really like you film. Because today I learn something new about hate crime that was going around the America about Sikhs. I think that you film is the best film in the America about hate crime.”
Hempreet,
 19-year-old male, Indian, Sikh

“I thought the film was insightful, honest, and inspiring. First, I think I was most impressed and in awe of your courage and determination in creating this amazingly wonderful film. I think this is the type of film that can really touch people and educate our society. I wish that all Americans can view a film as yours — to get through the bigotry and hate until all people can see others different from them as humans. You have inspired me to make true change in this world — and to do that beyond a status quo type life. Thank you for your hard work & valuable piece of art.

Suggestion: Show this film to audiences beyond the Sikh community — an open mind from this film can do many good!”
24-year-old female, Filipino, American citizen

“Good job with the film. Looks like you found your calling! God bless.”
Jesse Atwal
, 25-year-old male, Punjabi, Sikh

“I would love to be a part of your plans to better America. I would love your DVD. Thank you. I have an Indian friend that was taunted every day in school (I was a sophomore in high school), and thankfully there were people like me to stand up for her. You have wonderful ideas and you should be heard. I know Americans don’t really believe these ways of hate and evil.”
20-year-old female, many race/ethnicities, American citizen

“This film made me cry. A lot. I can’t even think of what to write. The Pierce brothers hit me hard. I cannot believe the reactions of those ‘Christians.’ I practiced Christianity for a time and heard racism and other intolerance at every church I met with. I was strongly questioning the strength of the Christian faith as I saw those men speak the name of Jesus while telling your cousin to leave the country. I realize that those who are not the best example of Christianity but… where do you hear tales of Sikh religious attacks on others? Why does Christianity leave such room for persecution? How can Jesus’ message of love be so ignored? I don’t know… I just felt the need to share.”
Brad
,19-year-old male, White, American citizen

“Thank you very much. God bless you.”
43-year-old female, Sikh, American citizen

“It is a great film. I commend you for making such a beautiful and meaningful film. This film can break barriers. Great for schools.”
Balbir S. Dhaliwal
,44-year-old male, Indian, Sikh, American citizen

“I really liked the film because it taught me that all people should be treated equally.”
Yasuwo Johnson,
13-year-old male, Micronesian citizen

“The film was great. I really liked it. You done a great job. I would really like to help you out. With anything.”
20-year-old female, Sikh

“Your film was absolutely AMAZING! I learned a lot and realized how important it is for Sikhs to unite. I have always tried to educate my community about my faith, but you have accomplished this above and beyond. Thank you so much for everything you did, do, and continue to do.”
17-year-old female, Punjabi, Sikh, American citizen

“I really would like you to share this info with the schools because I want people to understand us better.”
14-year-old female, Sikh, American/Indian citizen

“Very well done! Please try distributing this film to college groups – classes, interfaith groups, high schools. Encourage elected officials to show this film at a town hall meeting. I wish you the best at getting this film widely distributed. Inspiring!”
Marie Liu
,30-year-old female, Chinese-American

“What you did was admirable!! Thank you on behalf of those whose voices continue to not be heard — thank you for sharing these stories.

*Also — great that you tied in Japanese American internment and the hate crimes against Matthew Shepherd and James Byrd.”
26-year-old female, Vietnamese-American, Catholic

“To see this film we are very proud of you. You did a great job. May God bless you and give you good health and strength to keep up the good work to awaken the people. I can not say enough word to explain how proud I am. You did a great job which our people could not do it. Again I am very proud of you. God bless you.”
45-year-old female, Sikh, Proud to be Sikh American

“It is a very good documentary film on September the 11th and its aftermath. I strongly appreciate the hard work done by the team of this film. I congratulate you on this effort.”
66-year-old female, Sikh, Indian citizen

“You are so cool, passionate, awesome!”
23-year-old male, American/White, Catholic, American citizen

“Great film. Lot of hard work and a lot of first-hand information.”
56-year-old female, Indian, Sikh, American citizen

“Wow! I really admire your confidence. The life you have given to educate people is so unmatchable. You are comparable with Sant Jainail Singh Bhindranwale, who tried to save Sikh people, but you are doing a greater or bigger job than him teaching people that we all stand on the same platform and UNITED WE STAND. Where there is will, there is a way (that’s something you’ve proved). GOD BLESS YOU. And he is with you.”
20-year-old male, Indian, Sikh, Indian citizen

San Francisco

“Thank you Valarie. This film moved me to tears and deep humility. Your work and incredible bravery have inspired me to do more with my life. I am 25 years old. Your film reminded me of my dad, a Mexican, who intentionally grew his beard out after 9/11 to show solidarity with others who might be targeted. Thank you once again. Now I understand why he did that.”
25-year-old womyn, Chicana, American citizen

“This was such an incredible learning experience for me. The film touched me in ways to educate me in the Sikh cultur[e], empower[ed] me to move for change where I can and gave me hope that through small efforts differences can be made.

May you be blessed from the journey.”
40-year-old female, African-American, Christian, American citizen

“Incredibly touching and SO important. Thank you.”
20-year-old female, white, Jewish, American/Canadian citizen

“Excellent conversation not only with respect to 9/11 but what it means to be a U.S. citizen and the struggles with diversity within the U.S.

Great political conversation as well. I really admired a peer viewpoint and the voice of the film. In what seems as a defeatest mentality to create change in our generation, your film challenges those ideas, inspires activism.

 We should incorporate more individual stories/voices in our everyday lives.”
25-year-old male, white/European, Jewish, American citizen

“Excellent film! I was extremely moved by this — I would love to see it widely distributed and seen in the U.S., but really anywhere there is intolerance — meaningeverywhere.”
59-year-old female, Russian-Jewish, cultural Jew, American citizen

“I was a medical student rotating at Columbia University Medical Center in Northern Manhattan when 9/11 happened. After the horror of that day, I was told I could go home rather than staying on call overnight as planned. I was so scared to leave and ride on public transportation through the Bronx after hearing the stories of hate crimes occurring even that same day. I decided to stay at the hospital instead, but I felt intimidated and sad that I could not feel safe in my neighborhood and country. I am Indian and I have a nosering, but that shouldn’t matter. No Muslim person who looks like me should suffer hate through ignorance.”
28-year-old female, Indian/South Asian, Hindu, American citizen

“I wore a turban until I left my parents’ home at 18. In the wake of 9/11, though, I felt a tremendous survivor guilt over the fact that my father and his brother wore targets on their head while I did not. So I went to the fabric store and bought a bunch of fabric and started wearing a turban again (despite my lack of a beard — weird). The really beautiful thing was that several white friends of mine (white anti-capitalist activists) learned how to wrap a pagrhi from me and wore them in a public show of solidarity (as was suggested by the interfaith dude in your film).”
30-year-old male, Punjabi Jat, atheist (raised Sikh), American citizen

“A brilliant and moving film that shed light on ‘the wound’ of ignorance which led to hatred and violence after 9/11. You have ‘through action,’ brought to the world a profoundly spiritual and human portrait of the soul of America, its possibilities, triumphs, and failures. Thank you!”
39-year-old male, Indian, Buddhist, American citizen

“I had a very fully-grown beard for one year for a movie role. As a South Asian man, living in American post-9/11, I have empathized with those who have received prejudice and mistreatment for having beards, turbans, head coverings.. or just ‘being brown.’ In my own family, the men do not normally wear beards nor use head coverings. Once I had my beard, people’s perceptions of me CHANGED. I was viewed as ‘the enemy,’ ‘a terrorist,’ ‘an evil Muslim,’ etc… airport travel was rough to say the least. And I was just an actor with a beard. This movie of yours dramatically emphasized the continual struggle of those who wear beards/turbans every day for religion. My heart goes out, truly. Thank you eternally for your film.”
27-year-old male, East Indian, agnostic, American citizen

“Hi Valarie,

I am a grad student in Asian American studies at SFSU and I just absolutely LOVED the film!”
29-year-old female, Indian, Christian, Indian citizen

“Valarie, your work is truly exceptional and your video will be outstanding. I believe it’s release will be a landmark event in our community’s history. I wish I could put into words exactly what the DVD means to me, a 26 year old sardar [turban-wearing Sikh] in the same business as Balbir Sodhi was. Your work is necessary for me. And I wish I could throw you a Pizza Hut party afterwards just to explain my appreciation for you and your staff’s hard work, but since I will probably never meet you, all I can do is write it in this message. Thank you, Valarie.”
Ruminder S. Dhillon
, 26-year-old male, Sikh

“I am a 33-year-old Native American woman who is often lost in the trauma that American citizens often commit on/to one another. Your words on ‘I will take from you what you take from me’! Americans truly do live on these values. I am going to school to become a social worker. I have pledged to myself and for future generations to start a revolution on the way we treat each other not just Americans but all citizens. It is my belief that we are all a part of the human race. Thank you for putting such a strong young voice to such an old old issue.”
Cynthia Edison, 
33-year-old female, Native American, traditional religion, American citizen

“This is a very important story. Thank you for your courage, strength, determination and desire to share it. I have been touched in my heart. I learned about Sikhs and Sikhism in detail for the first time. Thank you for that. Thank you for sharing you. It has been a pleasure meeting you.”
Maria Apodaca,
42-year-old female, African-American, Christian, American citizen

“I was very moved by all of these stories, and I think that you and others telling these types of stories are the only way to get people to think about these issues.”
33-year-old female, white, Christian/spiritual, American citizen

“What a touching, amazing film! So well put together and very tastefully done. I learned so much and have a desire to learn more. Congratulation on such a wonderful accomplishent.”
21-year-old female, Hispanic, Christian, American citizen

“Extremely powerful film – very well done. I’m so grateful for the opportunity to see this film and thankful that you made this incredible documentary.”
46-year-old white female, 
San Francisco

“Truly amazing. Thank you for your knowledge, courage, dedication, and passion. You are an inspiration. Thank you.”
19-year-old female, American-Spanish-German, Jewish, American citizen

“I appreciated the part when the man said he was also Muslim, because he is considered/seen as that. (Obama says the same about being black.) I am interested in that Muslim experience, too — maybe later — not just that people in turbans are unfairly targeted — because the logical thing shouldn’t be that someone is — so there’s a next step.”
34-year-old female, White-Latina, U.S. citizen
, Society For Art & Cultural Heritage of India

“Excellent — very professional — Oscar material for sure! I think you’ve produced a film that makes people think and it will make a significant impact on the country when it is released nationally. Your film will make people see each other who are different than them in a different light.”
55-year-old female, White, Protestant – Methodist, U.S.A. citizen

“I thought the film was amazing. I’m white and female and as far from the profile of a terrorist as possible, but I’m only a couple of years younger than Valarie and it was hard watching my friends and classmates being victimized like this.

I was supposed to go to college on the East Coast (I’m Californian) the next year, and after September 11th I decided to stay in the state because it was this realization for me that anyone I love could be targeted for any reason and I needed to be close to them. I think this film is going to do a lot of good.”
24-year-old female, White, no religious affiliation, American (and British) citizen

“I applaud your concept of sharing stories, bringing us all together and reminding us of all we share. It was a very effective film bringing together all segments of American strands. And I am particularly touched by what one 20 year old with a vision can accomplish. Well done. One last part — I was drawn in from the first by the telling of Valarie’s story and background making me open for all the stories to come.”
54-year-old female, White, U.S. citizen

“I remember Tuesday 9/11 vividly, my golf day, watching events unfold on TV. My thoughts were about our reaction, and how many people would die because of our reaction. Unfortunately, my worst fears have come true.”
55-year-old male, White, USA citizen

“This film touched me on many, many levels; my life’s views & experiences. Open dialogue (PLANT THE SEED) WILL be stimulated by your distribution of this film!”
65-year-old female, German & Native American & Afro-American, 
Interfaith: practice Eastern Christian Western, USA citizen (Europe for 15 years)

“I hope that this very powerful story finds an audience among not only those who have experienced stories like those you have put in your film, but also those who have not been as exposed to other cultures and most need to learn and feel empathy for those who are different from themselves.”
36-year-old male, White, No religion, US citizen

“EXCEPTIONAL.
EYE OPENING.”
45-year-old male, Indian, Hindu, Indian citizen

“I thoroughly enjoyed the film. THe content was refreshing, insightful and entertaining. Both of you have a real handle on the art of storytelling and the message was very clear and intelligently portrayed. You should be truly PROUD of putting such a beautiful piece of social commentary and art in the world. Congrats! See you at the Oscar’s.”
33-year-old female, Southeast Asian/Indian, Hindu, U.S. citizen

“Great film from bright young kids.

Shocking horrible events not acceptable in U.S.A. But, one could also emphasize further how accepting America is and Americans are. Never the less, we need to have zero tolerance.”
61-year-old male, Indian, Hindu, U.S. Citizen

“I think it was great that you put things in a broader historical context by including the Japanese experience. When I was much younger, I was once called a ‘Jap’ and really did not get why – I had been called a ‘Paki; before but was puzzled by the ‘Jap’ – it was then that I learned about the history of Japanese during World War II. Whatever the term used, I was being identified as ‘other.’”
48-year-old female, Indian, lapsed Jain/Hindu mix, Indian citizen

“I have seen hatred on the part of my dear wonderful grandmother (who was 3rd generation San Franciscan, born 1881) and who hated the ‘Japs.’

Send a copy to Caroline Kennedy.”
65(+)-year-old female , White, agnostic, U.S. citizen

“Brought back memories of my first days in England @ age 17, when my innocence was shattered, just as it was for the young muslim boy in the film. I had no conception of my ‘difference’ from others until then. Every scene was poignant or hilarious. (Sonny is a real crack-up.) But I particularly appreciated your convolution of the violent cycle: attack, hate crime, death penalty. That guy Gietz in AZ has it right, of course, as does the Stanford social psychologist. This is a BEAUTIFUL film. Make many more.”
57-year-old male, Homo Sapien (incorrectly categorized as sub-continent Indian), No spiritual affiliation, U.S. citizen

“A great film. uplifting, hope burns eternal. Americans are like children who lack maturity, brought up to believe that ‘otherness’ is to be feared. Last 8 years of ‘fear mongering’ by the present [June, 2008] administration has only added to the paranoia. Perhaps a more “enlightened government leadership may bring a gradual change. An utopian view? Perhaps, but do not despair — man is capable of ‘divine’ action.”
75-year-old male, Asian-American, Vedic Hindu Sanatan – Dharma, U.S. Citizen

“This is a phenomenal film. Educational & enlightening, and beyond. The goal is to instill and ignite empathy among all of human kind. United we stand …. but divided we certainly fall — Excellent.”
25-year-old female, Indian, Hindu, U.S. citizen

“This film provides further validation on whether Indians ca really become ‘American.’ Yet most Americans cannot articulate what it means to be an American. The ignorance of a lot of Americans about other countries is quite astonishing, especially when one realizes that America is the most powerful, at least militarily, country in the world. Very scary.”
52-year-old male, Indian, Hindu, Indian citizen

“It was an informative film. I appreciated the openness to people sharing their stories. Valerie’s passion and commitment ot capture the stories is very much appreciated.

I hope there can be more dialogue about what fear can stimulate along with pressures or what provoked fear. I would also like to understand the other side.”
34-year-old female, East Indian, Skih, U.S. citizen

Stockton

Connecticut

New Haven

“Every high-school student should watch this film. Work it into history curriculums. Either with current issues or U.S. History, curriculums never spend enough time on contemporary events and years after Vietnam, AND WE NEED TO! This film not only educates audiences but stirs emotions and values and prejudices that some people never knew that they had. This documentary is great, I really appreciated it! Get it more widely distributed and released!”
21-year-old female, Asian/Taiwanese, American citizen
, East Coast Asian American Student Union Conference 2007, 
New Haven

“It was a great film which helped provide a snapshot into an area of American society I was not well aware about. As a member of the US military who will be leading soldiers of diverse backgrounds, it helped enlighten me to a different culture.”
21-year-old male, Asian, Christian, American citizen

“This film has touched me in so many ways, I don’t even know where to begin. First and foremost, thank you for making this film and the bravery and perseverance that you so effortlessly emit. I truly believe in your cause and some of your images reminded me of the vandalism that was shown on the news after 9/11 in NYC, and of all the American flags that were displayed with the intent to show others that they are ‘American.’ It has also opened my eyes to a community I had only heard about and am grateful to learn about Americans. Again, I am reminded of my own prejudices and that I must continue to question, to keep an open mind and to embrace others.”
21-year-old female, Chinese, American citizen (naturalized in 2006)

“Thank you so much for giving voice to the oppressed and the marginalized. So much is still left unheard, but your film is inspirational and energizing and a testament to the kind of change possible!”
19-year-old female, Asian, Christian, American citizen

“September 11 has always been the day before my birthday. 2001 was the year I turned 13. It was also the year that changed the way I looked at the world. The Middle East, primarily and initially Afghanistan, surprisingly in knowledge existed before 9/11/01 happened. It was the year before, 2000, part of the curriculum, I learnt about the Middle East and its culture. I thought that region was something I just needed to know for a test, but never thought it would reappear in my life. My ignorance of the region and the culture still exist (to some extent my fault). Your documentary change the way I want to continue my education.”
18-year-old female, Vietnamese, American citizen

“Valarie,

Divided We Fall is a poignant and very necessary narrative for our world today. I especially appreciate the depth and breadth of your reflections — your insight into today’s politics, sociocultural issues, your juxtaposition of Sikh discrimination and violence with that of other demographics. Thank you for sharing your voice and those of everyone you met. I think there’s a great courage and nobility in what you’re doing and I’m very, very glad to have encountered your work and you.”
Celia Ho, 
Northeastern University 2009, 
22-year-old female, Chinese, agnostic, American citizen

“Very important film. Thank you. Personal narratives are most effective for me. Beautifully done. I was surprised at my own lack of awareness of these incidents, especially in Southern California where I am from.”
37-year-old male, Filipino, American citizen

“My boyfriend is Indian-American from El Paso, TX. He told me a relatively comical story about his family’s experience in the aftermath of 9/11:

Police would pull his father or mother over who are both very prominent doctors in El Paso and once they would realize who they were, they would sheepishly say things like, ‘Oh, my brother’s doing great after your surgery,’ or something like that. Although the outcome was funny, the police’s intention was not.

Thank you for this film. Captivating the whole time.”
20-year-old female, Cantonese and White, American citizen

“I found this documentary rather moving and I think that this film should have been played alongside movies like ‘United 93′ and ‘World Trade Center.’ My reason in saying so is that this film may broaden American values and the way we ‘respect’ one another. Plus, making individuals, like Daniel Pierce and brother, look like complete fools. In addition, I found the Sodhi family story very moving and touching. I enjoyed it very much.’”
21-year-old male, Asian-Chinese, American citizen

“This is a great documentary film. I sincerely enjoyed it and tears welled up in my eyes during it from hearing real life experiences of those awful hate crimes. It makes me angry and ashamed that our country, our American people, were so ignorant.

I am glad you chose to make this film, to educate and spread the voices and stories of these people, victims. Please continue.”
19-year-old female, Chinese, American citizen

“I was clearly and consistently moved throughout the film and felt emotionally drained afterwards. I forsee having more reflection in the days to come. One detail I think is touched upon, but could been even further developed, is the interfaith concept of empathy and solidarity. In an effort to educate the audience about the differences of Sikhs and Muslims, I would have additionally wanted to hear/see more debunking of the myth that most/all Muslims are synonymous with terror.. instead of defining differences from Muslims, how can we as a society identify and unite with peaceful, innocent, scapegoated Muslims and others? (Thank you for discussing this interconnectedness in the Q&A session!) Best of luck in grad school. I hope to hear/see more from you in the future!”
27-year-old female, Chinese American citizen

“You guys have done a great job. This video needs to get out and shown to everyone. Can you distribute it on a larger scale? Show it in theaters?”
22-year-old female, Korean American, Christian, American citizen

“The movie was better than I envisioned. Moving, thought provoking and an opportunity for others to walk in your shoes. I hope I will be able to have this movie shown in my local theater soon.”
KeoOura Kounlavong,
Assistant Director of Admissions
,Lebanon Valley College (PA)
,28-year-old female, Lao, Mennonite, American citizen

“Thank you. There’s a double-hurt that Muslims/South Asians/Arabs had to face post-9/11 that I really connected to with people in the film — the hurt of having your country attacked and then of having your loyalty questioned. Thanks for capturing that.”
20-year-old female, Middle-Eastern, Muslim, Canadian citizen

“I just wanted to say how moving your film was. As a native of Sacramento, it was strange to see familiar headlines and scenes in the film as a much greater picture. The loss, the immigrant stories are really something that resonate with all of us.”
21-year-old female, Chinese, Buddhist, American citizen

“I thought it was really an amazing film. I found it especially informative because I did not know how much the rights of Sikh Americans were violated. I obviously knew about Muslims, but I think its very important for the country to know about how other Americans have been hurt as well, like Sikhs. I congratulate you on a great film and wish you good luck at the law school!”
18-year-old male, Pakistani-born/grew up in America, Muslim, American citizen

“Divided We Fall is one of the first films seen by me or even heard of at all. Valarie and her group have done an amazing job and have portrayed the facts and emotions so well. As a Sikh I feel proud to know there are people like Valarie who care enough to do something. Please keep up with the good work and wish you the best of luck! Thanks for realistically showing me what I knew but never felt!”
25-year-old female, Punjabi, Sikh, American citizen

“This film should be used in all Asian American Studies related classes (plus other fields as well), the release of this film in the form of DVDs can help a lot in the learning of multiculturalism.”
23-year-old male, East Asian, agnostic, American citizen (formerly Taiwanese citizen)

“It really gave the film emotional power in how intimate and personal the interviews were. The interviews with the eight-year-old boy and the nephew as well as the widow touched me the most. It was great how you added ending notes about most of the people on how they were doing after your initial interviews. Good luck on all your future tours and film festivals!”
20-year-old female, Chinese, American citizen

“So… I hope to talk to you, but in case I don’t, please realize that you guys are absolutely incredible — the honesty and love you project is incredibly refreshing. I look up to you. Thanks.”
Jaipal Singh,
26-year-old male, Punjabi, Sikh, American citizen

“This should be made into a film for screening across the nation in theatres and also entered into nation and international documentary films. This will attract lots of attention to it and to the harsh realities of hate crime in our world. May God bless you!”
Dr. Nawdh Motter, 
55-year-old male, East Indian, Sikh, American citizen

“I thought it was a good film that highlighted the fact that many Americans talk about freedom and say they live in the land of the free but are so ignorant and close-minded. Education is the way to correct this. Kudos.”
22-year-old male, Cambodian, Buddhist, American citizen

“Very moving, thoughtful documentary. It might be helpful in doing/contributing educational programs to use a couple of examples from your documentary if short on time. Thanks for making this documentary.”
24-year-old female, Asian American

“Great film, thank you for making this film. Good use of multiple groups of experts. I was very touched.”
22-year-old male, Korean-American, Christian, American citizen

“It really touched me on how the Sikh community felt because I was not aware, especially where I came from.”
18-year-old female, Vietnamese, American citizen

“Actually, just wanted to add that even though I grew up in an area with a lot of Sikhs I was not so familiar with the extent of the backlash.”
21-year-old female, Viet, American citizen

“Amazing work… remarkable message. Very thought provoking.”
25-year-old female, Vietnamese American, Buddhist, American citizen

“Beautifully and thoughtfully done; the result is too powerful for words. Keep the core of this you whatever you take on next.”
29-year-old, male, white, Presbyterian, U.S. citizen
, Yale Law School

“This is a story that needs to be told over and over to remind our country that we have a long history of hatred toward one another that continues today. Yet it is also a story of hope, that we can do better than our ancestors and act in love toward each other. I’m from Oklahoma and remember hearing about an American Indian [Native American] woman being hit by a car, post-9/11, deliberately, because she ‘looked’ Arab. I was profoundly saddened that a state which suffered so much in 1995 [Oklahoma City bombing] had so much hate rather than love to give.”
26-year-old, female, Caucasian, Christianity, U.S. citizen

“I FOUND MY OTHERNESS AND MY SAMENESS.”
28-year-old, female, Caucasian, Jewish, U.S. citizen

“I don’t have a racist bone in my body. Sometimes my friends and I laugh about how we look like some poster on diversity. So, I’m ashamed that when I fly, and see people in turbans waiting at the same gate, my heart races, my stomach gets tight and I get worried. I try to calm myself by pointing out to myself that they’re with wife and kids. My head does not agree with my emotional response, and it upsets me that the media, or what ever is at fault, has embedded this response in my subconscious. I loved your film and sincerely hope this reaches a wide, wide audience.”
26-year-old, female, white, no religious affiliation, U.S. citizen

“I was shock[ed] by the person who said, ‘We all want to be seen as we see ourselves.’ That’s such a powerful desire. I was also struck by the scene in Union Station with the guy who wants her cousin to accept Christ. I wonder if the connection between these two scenes is the danger of defining one’s self most deeply as Not Them instead of Me. It seems like we can most genuinely see each other when we know ourselves and are secure in ourselves without needing to be know as Not The Other. I felt like the [behavior?] in Union Station was the fragility of the man’s self — the need for others to be the same as him — the inability to see the other as they see themselves.”
27-year-old, female, white, Quaker, U.S. citizen

“It was a shock to my heart, my memory and my conscience. Though I grew up in Hawaii, I felt pretty removed from the internment camps of WWII and did not link it to the situation today following 9/11. I think your film is an amazing way to see the present while still having an awareness of historical and cross-cultural implications.”
23-year-old, female, Chinese – Thai, no spiritual affiliation, U.S. citizen

“I was moved to tears by this film; ashamed in many ways to be a part of the America portrayed, but also inspired by the message of love and hope that this beautiful film showed.”
24-year-old, female, white, Christian, U.S. citizen

“The movie was so moving and powerful. These are stories I’ve never heard before, but I feel more American and more empowered from having heard them. This film reinforces the importance of solidarity — among communities of color, among Americans. Valarie and Sonny — you had so much courage to act, you’ve inspired me. God bless you!”
23-year-old, female, Latina, U.S. citizen

“Thank you for sharing this story of what Sikh Americans have been experiencing. So many of us Americans have immigrant backgrounds, so the story of being made other or made to feel outsiders is one that resonates, that feels, in some strange way, very American. Not quite the positive vision of America that so many of us cherish, but American nonetheless.”
23-year-old, female, white, Jewish, U.S. citizen

“This film is incredibly important and reminds us all to be led by love and not fear.”
25-year-old, female, Catholic, U.S. citizen

“Thank you so much for this. I have a Sikh friend who has discussed this with me, with a humor that doesn’t hide how deep his bitterness is. Thank you for sharing these stories — I look forward to giving him this movie so he wil know that these stories are being heard.”
27-year-old, female, Caucasian, Agnostic / Jewish, U.S. citizen

“I don’t know that I will ever reach the forgiveness that Valerie and the protagonists of this film embody — I am still angry — on behalf of my clients and due to my own sense of betrayal of American values. But I do know that justice will keep beyond the reach unless we can recognize community in each other — and that demands that we risk something of ourselves. And, I thank you for that.”
34-year-old, female, Anglo, Unitarian, U.S. citizen

“I recently drove through California and saw the desert camp — Manzanar — where Japanese-Americans were interned. I was grateful to my eighth grade English teacher who had us read Farewell to Manzanar. If not, I never would have known what happened in that desolate place. am terrified of hate crimes against lesbians and queer people, and I wish that I were not afraid to be myself and express myself.”
24-year-old, female, white, no religious affiliation stated, U.S. citizen

“A Beautiful Movie — on 9/11, when the planes crashed, I had just come home from school in Jerusalem and my grandma called me and told me to turn the TV on, that something terrible has happened — I turned it on and watched in horror. I remember my only clear thoughts amidst all the confusion were: “S***, We (Arab, Muslims) are gonna have it bad. Please don’t let it be a Muslim.”
24-year-old, female, Arab, no religious affiliation stated U.S. / Palestinian citizen

“It is time. We have all been on the other side. Thank you for being honest and sharing.”
27-year-old, female, Korean, agnostic, U.S. citizen

“After crying for the first hour of the movie, thinking to myself how horrible it was that such a thing could happen to an American minority, I was so touched to see the discussion with Japanese-American survivors of internment camps, because my step-grandfather and his parents were put in one of those camps, and I had the reaction – I know these people. You’re right when yo say this story has happened many times before, but it’s touching to see something this beautiful and moving come out of it.”
22-year-old, female, white, Catholic, U.S. citizen

“It was a beautiful experience to share this evening with others who believe in equality, human rights, and hope. I couldn’t help but think of those who were not here tonight, those that do not share this vision. I especially think of witnessing the annual KKK rally as a child that happened in the town next to the one I grew up in in the midwest. After your experience, I am curious as to your thoughts on how to engage those who are not here, the empty chairs?”
26-year-old, female, white, Unitarian, U.S. citizen

“It’s an old story in a new package, sensitively done and compassionately told. The Sikh perspective is unique in this expose’ of racial, religious, and ethnic hatred all too common in this country against anyone different. Brava!”
64-year-old, male, Caucasian, Roman Catholic, U.S. citizen

“Loved the film. Thanks for helping us to reflect about who we are, and when does intolerance start to make us that which we wouldn’t like to be.”
26-year-old, male, Latino, Catholic, Chilean citizen

“As a black man in the U.S., it has been truly inspiring to see a film that so eloquently depicts the struggle and crisis of another demographic, having been discriminated myself in medical school, hospitals, airports and on the streets of this country. I live your film and am grateful to your vision.”
25-year-old, male, Black (Caribbean), Roman Catholic, Bahaman citizen

“While I’m generally skeptical of group emotional experiences, Valerie’s genuine desire to bring people together and to share her story and to hear other people’s stories mad this a genuinely powerful experience for me and I’d like to thank her and everyone involved in this film.”
25-year-old, male, white, no religious affiliation, U.S. citizen

“Prof. Muneer Ahmad for Attorney General!”
29-year-old, male, white, Just Barely Jewish, U.S. citizen

“Everyone in America should see this film.

What’s strange to me is the randomness of the hatred. I’m pretty sure I look like a few of the 9/11 hijackers, but I have never experienced discrimination even at airports.”
27-year-old, male, Indian, Hindu, U.S. citizen

“This film was so timely and that’s the thing — it always will be. While the events took place right after 9/11, these issues are and unfortunately will always be something we have to think about.”
No age, no name,
Yale Law School

“Impressive production, Valerie. I look forward to spending the next three years getting to know you, post-film.”
26-year-old, male, white, Christian, U.S. citizen

“This film is a powerful, challenging call to arms — but not the arms of war but those of story telling, understanding, and love. Thank you for making such an inspiring film.”
27-year-old, male, white, Catholic, U.S. citizen

“Thank you. I have nothing more complicated to say.”
29-year-old, male, white, no religious affiliation stated, U.S. citizen

“I grew up in a farming community where everyone knew everyone. I never gave the subject of religion a thought during my early childhood. There was a God. I knew that because my mother swore in his name. As a seven-year-old child, I found out the disturbing truth that I was going to hell because I was not baptized. The future of religion and a pluralistic society together is a future that I want, but I don’t know how it will be reached. This movie gave me so much hope.”
23-year-old, male, white, no religious affiliation, U.S. citizen

“An amazing narrative of the stories that escape the sieve of law and the threshold of personal moralities.”
25-year-old, male, Indian, raised Hindu, but now Atheist, U.S. citizen

“Need more of this perfect example for all races.”
36-year-old, male, Latino, Independent (religion), Peruvian (Lima) citizen

Storrs (UConn)

“This was an incredibly inspirational work. It sheds light on a very misunderstood community while at the same time highlighting the similarities that unites all of us. I wish you good luck in spreading the message of this film and will do my part in helping you do so.”
30-year-old male, Filipino, Canadian citizen

“Thank you so much for bringing light to an often, and unfortunately, overlooked issue.

I was a freshman in college on 9/11. My dorm room was on the 11th floor of a residence hall overlooking the Manhattan skyline. While I was removed from the immediate area, the impact in my being was profound. I saw people band together and I also saw people oppressed (i.e. people perceived to be Muslim). You do a great job illustrating this.”
23-year-old female, biracial, Catholic, American citizen

“I was very shocked at the amount of ignorance displayed by some Americans specifically the passer-by in the train station. At the same time, it gave me joy to see the love shown by the community in Arizona. I want to believe that we can as a country work to get rid of the ignorance and to show as much compassion as possible. I appreciate the efforts you have taken to promote this movement from hate to love.”
17-year-old male, Italian, Christian, American citizen

“As a (progressive) Southerner, I often feel like I am stereotyped as a bigot, or as a racist, simply because people feel that may have been my upbringing or culture. Watching this, especially the ‘Christians’ who said ‘go home’ and then made a feeble attempt to proselytize, I immediately felt ashamed to be ‘one of them’ and I realized that I am not one of them, that there is no such ‘them,’ just as there is no such ‘Muslim terrorist,’ there are only the mistaken and the wrong.”
25-year-old male, White, Christian (Southern Baptist), American citizen

“I thought the movie was very well made and informative. I personally was not served at a restaurant post-9/11 and this movie resurfaced the feeling I did then and I feel and I hope the movie evoked the same feelings in others too.”
Shally Sinha,
3rd generation Indian American

“In the place where I work, I often see coworkers judge and mistreat people of various racial and ethnic backgrounds. It angers me to no end and makes me feel that I need to be extraordinarily kind and friendly to make up for all those who act out of hate and misunderstanding. Thank you for spreading truth, challenging ignorant hate, and sharing insight.”
20-year-old woman, White, Christian, American citizen

“During December of 2001, I was shopping at the mall and went to Friendly’s to get some ice cream. I asked for vanilla ice cream with two scoops and sprinkles. The cashier gave me vanilla with one scoop and no sprinkles. I asked her to give me what I wanted and she furiously replied, ‘What else do you want, haven’t you people done enough?’”
22-year-old female, Indian, Hindu, American citizen

“This film found me in a freshly saddened place, though primarily addressing the first couple of years after September 11, 2001. I probably was aware of the heartbreaking stories of the unjust hate crimes that happened in the wake of the attack, but as the years have passed and more tragedies occur, these particular stories got buried. Sadly however, at my historically Quaker (a strongly pacifist religion) liberal arts school (college), which claims to honor the values of equality, justice, diversity, a similar hate crime (to those portrayed in the film) recently occurred against a couple Palestinian students attending Guilford. It is shocking to me that the fear and hate continues, and even in our liberal, educated, communities. Thank you for fighting this, spreading humanization, and telling these stories.”
22-year-old woman, Irish, Quaker, Irish/American citizen

“As a white male, I have never personally experienced discrimination — beyond the mild suspicion that because I am white and male, I must be racist/sexist. Nonetheless — because I abhor the sorts of ignorance of the hate crimes and less obvious – I was really moved by this film. I generally associate with a moderate and liberal people, some of whom nonetheless harbor vague, subtle precursors to bigotry, that they are unaware of. You need to reach them — and you already do, in so many ways. One way is by not over-simplifying the story — by not dwelling on victimhood. Keep up the good work.”
Chris Sampson
43-year-old male, Caucasian/Euro-American, spiritual agnostic, American citizen (third generation)

“AMAZING! We, Sikhs, need people like you to step up and actually do something. You have encouraged and motivated me to step up to the spotlight, something that I have been debating about for too long.”
22-year-old female, Asian American, SIKH!! couldn’t be more PROUD!, American citizen

“I loved the raw, interview dialog and spaces that were kept in the making of Divided We Fall. We’re used to seeing media in so many forms devoid of real stories, experiences and voices. Thank you for your work, effort, sacrifices in making this powerful educational tool.”
27-year-old female, White/Caucasian, Christian, American citizen

“As a white Australian, I have experienced a kind of reverse racism here in America. I have been accepted as a greater, more interesting person than I really am. But at the same time, I have seen the racism of both America and Australia that I would not have seen had I not been an immigrant.”
35-year-old female, White, Australian citizen

“You guys did a wonderful job. Simply amazing. Singapore is an interesting place as it has managed to carefully organize the Chinese, Malays, Indians and Eurasians. However, its one-third the size of Rhode Island and cannot be compared to America’s ethnic mix. I am an international exchange student and since I’ve been here, I have been observing and hearing stories from Americans and its been a wonderfully eye-opening experience. It’s so different from Europe, Brazil, and Asia but so very interesting. Your film made me laugh, made me cry, especially when the widow in India cried. It made my heart experience what it experienced when I lost family members. However, the very fact that she lived in another country most of her married life and still showed such intense pain and suffering really shook my core. I’d really like to bring your film and experience to Singapore, and I know how much people will appreciate it. Come visit! Thank you SO MUCH.”
Dhania C Nair
,20-year-old female, Indian, Hindu (by birth, still searching…), Singaporean citizen

“We need to be one in all aspects of loving and caring; we must understand we are all members of the same village. We are not really different. We just like to think we are: because we have some kind of indemnity problem. The only important thing is we all care about one another and all other living things. It is said there is no path to peace but that peace is the path! Hate began hate — love begans love. There is the choice.”
61-year-old male, Anglo-Saxon, Humanist, American citizen

“My grandfather could not become a citizen because he came from Germany illegally.

I have been called a terrorist by President Bush because I did not believe in either war. I protested in NY when I was held in barricades by the police who rode horses at me at everyone else in the crowd.

The media has simply not reported the dissent. Apparently it is un-American??? I thought our strength was in diversity.”
59-year-old female, White Anglo-Saxon Protestant, Protestant/Congregationalist, American citizen

“Although the movie and emotions are relatable for me, the film rejuvenated my thoughts and beliefs on prejudice. It made me realize how difficult it is to accept the intolerance of others; hence, it makes me want to do something to change that. I can’t do much but I hope the little things I can do to prevent prejudice will help stop hate crimes. The day after 9/11 I remember walking home from school and having a person hold a gun at me telling me to go back to my country and yelling racial slurs. It’s difficult to even accept that I did nothing about it.”
20-year-old female, Indian, Hindu, American citizen

“Thank you for making this documentary. I applaud you and your team for your hard work and dedication. Thank you for giving the opportunity for making so many voices heard. I hope you continue to show your film and educate people.

 On a more personal note… I apologize on behalf of Christians that you were pressured to convert and also your encounter with the Christian brothers shown in the film. I hope that God will continue to give opportunities to show your film and educate the world, giving a voice to those who go unheard.

 You have inspired me to also create change in this world as I pursue my human rights and health major.”
20-year-old female, Korean American, Presbyterian Christian, American citizen

“I believe you are brave to have taken this quest with such passion. The film is not only about the people in front of the camera, but also those behind it, their growth and struggles, their voices crying to be heard. The film is timeless in the way that it isn’t just about 9/11 or Sikh-Americans, it is a socially energizing piece that is about anyone who has been a victim of blind ignorance. Thank you.”
23-year-old male, Caucasian, American citizen

“The film was a truly moving experience for me. As president of the Indian Students Association [at UConn], I understand the discrimination that exists and is kept well hidden in the United Stated. Your documentary offers tremendous hope for the future of the country and brings me personal faith that one person really can make a difference. Recently I have applied to law schools, focusing on a career in public interest law, and people like you are those I hope to strive to be and work with in the future. I am honored to have been able to view the Connecticut premiere, and be here with you and your cast.”
21-year-old female, Indian American, Hindu, American citizen

“I would like to thank you tremendously for showing me what life was like for you and the Sikh community and others that suffered after the September 11th attacks. I think that it takes a film like this to really enlighten an entire country. It shows that we as Americans must understand that being American does not have anything to do with how you look. Thank you for reminding us for that.”
21-year-old male, Indian, Hindu, American citizen

“The film was absolutely amazing and I really do believe that all college students (universities) should have an opportunity to see it because change is going to be implemented at the level of a younger generation. I think that like Valarie, many students will be affected by the film and will take opportunities to educate the ignorant people.”
21-year-old female, Indian, Hindu, American citizen

“This was an amazing experience for me. I cannot begin to express my appreciation for the encouragement of people to ask ignorant questions so we can ALL learn. I find that too often people are too afraid to ask which causes the ignorance to grow. FOREVER thankful!”
24-year-old female, white, American citizen

“This was such a touching documentary that brought tears, but more importantly, new light to the events after 9/11. So much is lost and it would be foolish to ignore it. Thank you so much for this experience.”
18-year-old female, Asian-Chinese, Christian, American citizen

“I just want to say, congratulations, you made an absolutely wonderful film. Every American should watch this as not only a learning tool, but a reality check.

After 9/11, I was one of FEW who felt sorrow for the Muslim (and now I’ve learned many more) groups. This film conveys just how everyone should understand how America should work. Great job.”
21-year-old female, White, American citizen

“I think this film was very necessary and people should watch it. I’m sure many Americans have questions about Sikhs, Hindus, Muslims but aren’t sure where to go or who to ask about them. It is necessary for people to understand the difference between Sikhs and terrorists.”
19-year-old female, Indian-American, Hindu, American citizen

“As an aspiring filmmaker, I thank you for your vision. Hate breeds hate. Your film is the antithesis, and perfect example of opening the way for peace, tolerance, and understanding. If I may borrow the words of John Lennon, thank you for giving peace a chance.”
Corey Buckley, 
17-year-old male, Caucasian, Roman Catholic, American citizen

“As a high school English teacher of American literature in a predominantly “WASP” town – I find at least once a year the misconcept addressed in Divided We Fall… I would incorporate this film in my curriculum. Thank you.”
52-year-old female, Anglo-Italian, spiritual humanitarian, American citizen

“This film brought me to the painful realization that such violence happen after Sept. 11. I always heard rumors of anti-Muslim/Arab attacks post 9/11 but could never quite understand. Now I am beginning to. THANK YOU!”
Haley, 
21-year-old female, White, Christian, American citizen

“The film was very well done! It was amazing to hear the stories of those that have suffered because of September 11th that I really wasn’t aware of. I learned about the Sikh religion and I think the film promotes even more diversity and ideas of acceptance.”
21-year-old female, white, American citizen

“I am so inspired by your wisdom, courage and strength. What a painful yet empowering undertaking! It shows how a small group of people can contribute so much, and how critical your contribution is. This has opened up an amazing path for you. Keep up the fight, and the great work! The film was amazing.”
51-year-old female, White, Unitarian Universalist, American citizen

“Incredible injustice always makes me cry. This was a powerful documentary showing just one more example of discrimination and racism that our patriarchal system fosters through foreign and public policy.”
21-year-old female, White, American citizen

“This film was great. I learned a lot about Sikhism, although I have studied it. I was previously unaware of this backlash (to the extent of murders). I’m glad you brought up the irony in the death penalty for Roque (violence – retaliation – justice — all cyclical violence).”
25-year-old female, White, raised Jewish but not practicing now, American citizen

“This was a very powerful and eye-opening documentary. I would suggest that everyone watch it because education is the only way we can learn about each other. I wish you the best of luck!”
21-year-old female, Caucasian, Pagan, American citizen

“Before this film I had never heard of Sikhism. I do not know why this is, but I don’t like the fact that I was so ignorant to what was happening. I was not aware of Sikhism, let alone how Sikhs were being treated in the aftermath of the incidents on September 11, 2001. I’m very glad to have the chance to see this film and a chance to correct my ignorance.”
20-year-old male, white, agnostic, American citizen

“Thank you so much for opening my eyes. Keep up the good work! I’m planning on becoming a Christian minister to combat ignorance and teach that we are all the same and no religion condones violence.”
Dave Virone,
18-year-old male, Italian, Christian, American citizen

“The film was very well done! It was amazing to hear the stories of those that have suffered because of September 11th that I really wasn’t aware of. I learned about the Sikh religion and I think the film promotes even more diversity and ideas of acceptance.”
21-year-old female, white, American citizen

“This movie put things in perspective for me. It showed me that the things I have experienced (going from American to outsider, feeling paranoid and afraid on two sides) are really part of a larger phenomenon that is prevalent in our society today. Because your movie spoke to me so well, I would really like to do something to change these stereotypes and prejudices. Thank you so much for this movie.”
17-year-old female, Caucasian/Indonesia, Muslim, American citizen

“This film really opened my eyes to actual hate crimes that I didn’t know happened. Thank you for making this film! The only criticism or comment is about Daniel Pierce. I understand the reason for talking to him, however what he said made it look like all Christians think or approach Christianity like him. However, I am glad that the both of you responded to him in a civil and tolerant manner. But, I do appreciate the comments from the Japanese Americans about the Christians who gave them food as they boarded the train. Anyways, this film helped me learn much more about the realities and injustices in our own country.”
20-year-old female, Vietnamese, Protestant, American citizen

“Your film made me present myself to others as a Korean more proudly than ever. Thank you for your braveness and encouragement.”
19-year-old female, Korean, Protestant, Korean citizen

“Wonderful, insightful film — I will be sharing it with several friends and colleagues. Your hard work and travel (which I know is exhausting) was well worth it! Thank you.”
27-year-old female, White, Roman Catholic, American citizen

“I am gladdened by this movie and I hope that this will serve to educate Americans who are ignorant about hate crimes and racial profiling. Thank you for all your work on this very powerful, great film.”
22-year-old male, Filipino, Roman Catholic, American citizen

“I think that this movie did a great job showing how hate crimes still exist. By doing this and by making people aware the problem will be addressed.”
25-year-old male, Black, Jewish/Muslim, American citizen

“Thank you very much! This film reinstated my realization that action needs to be taken, and knowledge needs to be acquired to make a change — which in itself is needed. Best of luck with everything — both with the film and everything in life. Thank you for an educational and inspiring evening!”
18-year-old female, Caucasian, atheist, American citizen

“I cried/laughed. This film was motivating and inspiring. Everyone needs to see this film.”
23-year-old female, White, Catholic

“This movie opened my eyes to a world I didn’t know about, a must see.”
Shrina Amin
,20-year-old female, Indian, Hindu, American citizen

“Amazing job!! Even at the universities color matters to some students and I have gone through the discrimination. Divided we fall.”
23-year-old female, Hindu, Indian citizen

“I think the movie was really good. It really brought tears to my eyes.”
21-year-old female, Indian, Muslim, American citizen

“Seeing the faces of victims of hate crimes gave a more vivid picture of what is occurring in today’s society.”
18-year-old male, Chinese, American citizen

“I thought that this was a very eye opening and inspirational film.”
19-year-old female, Chinese, Buddhist, American citizen

“Thank you for making this film. It brought tears to my eyes and I hope this film will bring about a change.”
21-year-old female, Hmong, sacrifical animist, American citizen

“Amazing story. Very touching and educational. Thank you.”
19-year-old male, White, agnostic, American citizen

“It was wonderful. I learned a lot and can’t wait to share the info with others!”
25-year-old female, White/Polish/Italian, American citizen

“I was very moved. Thank you for documenting history — and create a teaching/healing tool.”
23-year-old female, White, Catholic, American citizen

“Thank you so much for taking on this project.”
67-year-old male, Caucasian, Christian, American/French citizen

Delaware

“Excellent — I will purchase it and use it in a course I teach at UD — I am so proud of your accomplishments and grateful — Valarie — just very impressive and it needed to be said/filmed. You will win major awards if you have not already won them.”
63-year-old female, Caucasian, progressive Protestant Christian, American citizen

“After 9/11 I anticipated some sort of backlash against Indians, Pakistanis, and those with brown skin. As a native of DE, I had only heard of some vandalism of the local Hindu temple. I came to see Divided We Fall in order to find out the other stories, those belonging to a non-oblivious 16-year-old. This movie was powerful, emotional, and a real eye opener. I never knew there were such acts of violence against Sikhs and others labeled as ‘terrorists.’ I would like to thank you for making this movie and bringing such incidents and issues to the public at large!”
22-year-old female, Indian, Hindu American citizen

“I’ve studied these concepts of racism and intergroup threat as well as the philosophy of nonviolence. In as much as these studies have provoked my thoughts upon such evil truths this film has identified, I think it’s important to look to the root cause. Hate is evil. Love is good. The golden rule must abound. Love one another. Does it come naturally? Certainly not. Our human nature is filled with sin. I know that it’s essential to seek God in our efforts to satisfy the golden rule. Nonetheless, no matter what or who you put your faith in, morality is put upon our heart, and justice is to uphold that. I’m glad you identified the danger that our government leaders have created in solving problems in fear and punishment rather than love.”
23-year-old male, Caucasian, Christian, American citizen

“I was surprised that Sonny didn’t feel passionate to share the meaning of wearing his turban to himself. In learning about Sikhs I understood it to be a sign of devotion but was interested to hear more about the values and meaning it holds. If Sikhs would share more about their beliefs and how the turban symbolizes that it might change people’s opinions who simply ask them to take it off.”
24-year-old female, white, Christian, American citizen

“Humanistic connection changes everything. Love the ideas/issues raised in the film. In an idealistic world, everybody would be good, but human nature, culture, and values within make the world scary at times.”
26-year-old male, Indian, Jain, American citizen

“This film helped open my eyes even more towards discrimination and hate towards others. I learned so much from this film and it has changed my life and my thoughts toward other races and religions.”
19-year-old female, white, Catholic, American citizen

“I very much appreciate the effort and time taken to bring such important observations to light. Oral history is integral to the growth of a society. This is the true history of a country and its people. Thank you for continuing this tradition.”
38-year-old female, Caucasian, atheist, American citizen

“I think that there were a couple of guys (two mainly, in the train station) that give Christians a bad light. Oftentimes we see those that do not represent all of us but that is what is always portrayed and gives viewers the wrong impression. I was impressed with the interviews you were able to get and commend you for the quality of the film.”
24-year-old female, Black, Jamaican-American, Christian, American citizen

Florida

Orlando

“Valarie, I am still talking about your touching and insightful film that I saw on Saturday evening. This film is a must for our children all to see and discuss. The way we eradicate hate, prejudice, and ignorance is through education. My feeling is that you should distribute this film to every high school in the US. I know that that is not possible and is a great expense but I think we can start at a grassroots level and expose this wonderful film of yours. As I said in the discussion after the film, I was touch by the universal message that we all can do something to make this a better world. I am an American born man of the Jewish faith. I lived in Israel for 6 years. I am the grandson of Eastern European immigrants that escaped persecution and the holocaust. Many of my family members were wiped out by the mere fact that they were different. We must all unite against bigotry and hate. Just like the minister from the interfaith council said so prophetically in the film….We should all unite around the Sikh community and wear turbans, so did the King of Sweden make a stand for his Jewish subjects in not being deported by the Nazis. In defiance he wore a yellow star as did all Swedes so that the Nazis could not distinguish between Jew and Gentile. This story always has stayed with me. I use this example when I teach the lesson of bravery and how one individual can make a difference. The king and the Swedish people brought light to this dark period of history and made such a difference. Our faith teaches us, ‘If you save one life, it is as if you have saved the world.’ Let me know how I could personally help and spreading your message and your lesson of faith and love to our younger generation.”
Jordan Miller, 
Owner, Money Mailer of Central Florida
, Global Peace Film Festival, 
Orlando

“Thank you for your tender presentation of the effects of ignorance and fear on the lives of victims and survivors of hate crimes. It was authentic, not angry; consequently, the raw truth is revealed. My heart is opened by the stories of your film, and I’m moved to learn more about how we can unite.”
42-year-old female, Caucasian, Buddhist, American citizen, 
South Asian Film Festival
, Orlando

“Amazing film! I hope the whole world watches it, or — at least — all of America. :O) As a white “dude,” I did not suffer hate from others, but I did have friends (roommates from UAE with whom I stayed with after being advised to stay indoors after 9/11. I am glad there is a film that brings this to light. :O)”
30-year-old male, Latino, American citizen

“My story is set in India. I remember 1984 and Indira Gandhi’s assassination but I am from Calcutta and did not know about the 1984 riots mainly in Delhi. Cut to 20 years later — I now live and work in Delhi and routinely tease my friend Manjit with “sardar jokes.” [A "sardar" is a Sikh man who wears a turban.] Anyhow we are all sitting around one evening and Manjit suddenly gets really mad and walks out visibly upset. I follow him and for the first time in our five years of friendship, he tells me of being a four-year-old when the riots happened, and how his parents cut off his and his brother’s hair in order to make them feel ‘safe.”‘ That was the first time I remember looking at Sikhs and thinking what it took for the them to assimulate to India!”
29-year-old female, East Indian/Hindu, agnostic, Indian citizen

“I admire your curiosity and courage. What an old soul resides in your youthful persona. Thank you for asking questions that are central to us all. Your film invited me to examine my own heart as well as my own flaws. Your film is a gift.”
59-year-old female, Caucasian, American citizen

“I am totally aligned with the perspectives conveyed in this film. And yes, please try to drive the film into the schools.”
60-year-old female, Caucasian/Italian-American, American citizen

“Great documentary and very informative. An Indian guy at my university was beat up after 9/11 simply because he was of ‘brown skin.’ This film hit home. Furthermore, my grandfather came to the USA in a steamboat and became a U.S. citizen… I am a second generation Indian American, and I could relate to the story (your history) you shared.”
24-year-old female, Indian, Hindu, American citizen

“Thank you for your film. I think you were not only telling the story of Sikhs in the U.S., but everybody who is in minority — whether race, gender, or religious affiliation. Thank you.”
28-year-old female, mixed (Asian/Hispanic/Caucasian), Jehovah’s Witness, American citizen

“Valarie,

You deserve a standing ovation. This is a film that must be shown in every classroom of the U.S. so our children grow up without fear and racism. 

THANK YOU FOR YOUR LOVE FOR THE U.S. AND YOUR FAITH IN YOUR RELIGION.”
Preeti Bhutani
, 41-year-old female, Sikh, American citizen

“Civil rights are being dragged under our need for security. We “fight them here” so we don’t have to fight them there. This attitude has made Americans value our lives more than somebody whose face we do not have to see.

As the mother of two grown sons, one who wears a beard, I am constantly worry about them being stopped at airports, detained. What I would like to see is an end to ignorance and lies about what America truly is. We are a nation of tolerance who have become blind to this fact.

As long as we are willing to give up our freedoms to be safe, we will not be safe or free. Prejudice is something I have seen in India also.”
64-year-old Asian Indian, American citizen

“Valerie said this back page is for ‘my story.’ I feel humbled to have to admit I do not have any stories which show discrimination, ignorance, etc against me. Therefore Ivow to open up to all around me, to simply greet people and smile, in an endeavor to carry on the education I have received via this film.”
57-year-old female, white/Caucasian, Buddhist, British citizen

“A powerful documentary… don’t believe its inherently different anywhere… 1984 in Delhi (as your movie); 1993 in Mumbai; 7/7 in the U.K. The key challenge is to move away from religion and country to origin to being in the here and now… as world citizens…”
Naresh N Sharani
,44-year-old male, Indian citizen

“A theme that was not brought out much was what do the common people do with their feelings of outrage after the initial terrorist act, in light of the fact that 99% are not involved in the justice process? I and my family lived in Kenya when the embassy was bombed in 1998. In that incident and in 9/11 both, nobody could catch the real culprits, to pour out justice where it really belonged. So they turned on each other, anyone who was ‘handy.’ In Kenya we saw and heard people say it was America’s fault for being so ‘bad’ that terrorists wanted to punish us! — and, significantly, catch Africans in the crossfire. They insisted America pay all damages as if we were the culprits — which we did, just out of decency. This generalizing of outrage and frustrated justice is typical human and part of the reason for the violence that occurred after 9/11 — NOT to excuse it!”
50-year-old female, Caucasian, Christian, American citizen

“I really enjoyed the film. This film is a wonderful teaching tool for people of all ages and races. I’m glad you included the Japanese ‘interment’ camps. Thank you for your dedication.”
27-year-old male, white, American citizen

“I must congratulate you for having made this instructive documentary at a young age. Hope every person in America sees this film and learns from it.”
Pralep Kale, 
71-year-old male, Hindu, Indian, American citizen

“My story: Although I was nowhere near NYC on 9/11/01, just by the fact that I was perceived to be different and might be in danger, my family, particularly my DAD was so petrified that he passed away 10 days later on 9/21/01!! Albeit, he had a weak heart, but all the fear perhaps made it weaker. Bless you!”
Amita, Engineer

“I wish you the best with this film and your personal journey in life. You have educated people and made an impact on society’s views.”
30-year-old female, East Asian, Sikh, American citizen

“I hope a lot of people are able to watch this film. It is a great source to learn about different cultures and the society we live in. Everyone can learn something from this film.”
24-year-old female, Indian, Hindu, American citizen

“Excellent we need to do a lot more on a continuous basis and work harder together on a national level for us and for our future generations.”
46-year-old male, Sikh, American citizen

“You are a very intelligent and brave young lady. You have made a very powerful, emotional movie.”
61-year-old male, Indian, Canadian citizen

“This was a nice insight on a cruicial topic and the necessity of the hour. Good job.”
38-year-old female, Asian, Hindu, Indian citizen

“The movie brought about a mix of emotions and questions. I was very unaware of the many stories that were told and have become compelled to ask questions and gain awareness. I’m blown away by the effort and pure honesty of the film. It is so painful to witness this aspect of the country I live in, however without education and attention nothing will change. The film opened my eyes to a new way of looking at the world in relation to me. Thank you so much for your hard work and dedication, it is greatly appreciated.”
female, 18-25 age range, 
Global Peace Film Festival
, Orlando

“This film needed to be made and we are so lucky to get the opportunity to see such a wonderful documentary. I was unaware of all these stories, being so young when all this happened. Movies like this only help us get rid of all the ignorance and hatred that surrounds us.”
female, 18-25 age range

“My response to the movie was it brought up a topic many push aside. It raised awareness to something many people are ignorant about. It was a powerful way to learn about something everyone, especially Americans, should know about.”
female, 18-25 age range

“After seeing this film I have a better grasp of what happened. I was in high school during 9-11, small Midwestern town, and didn’t see/hear much of the events following this act. It is very important, I think, for everyone to see how much of an impact certain events can have on different groups of people. CNN was always on my t.v. at home but I don’t recall hearing much about these hate crimes. I hope there will be many more people to have a positive change and attitude towards this documentary.”
female, 18-25 age range

“This movie was very touching to me. It told a story which is often forgotten but needs to be told. I truly enjoyed the film and want to thank you for making it. When I think of 9/11 I don’t normally think about this side of the story.”
female, 18-25 age range

“Seeing this film made me realize just how much discrimination there still is here. I knew that there was, but until I saw it from this point of view, I never really understood it. I truly believe that if more people had this understanding, maybe there would be peace. We never truly understand what someone else is going through until we walk a mile in their shoes.”
female, 18-25 age range

“This film was extraordinary film that should be shared with as many people as possible. The film was beautifully moving and has the power to affect and educate anyone. I think only of my favorite quote: ‘There is no way to peace, peace is the way.’”
female, 18-25 age range

“This film opened my perspective of hate crimes and discrimination throughout the nation. This film exposed me to different discriminations in our nation.”
female, 18-25 age range

Miami

“Stories like these need to be told, not glossed over or forgotten. The media works on fear, because people are more easily controlled when they are afraid. We as individuals need to stand up and correct this behavior. I enjoyed your film immensely. Good for you, keep spreading the message.”
Rachel Salit
, 28-year-old female, White, Jewish, American citizen

“I loved the film. It reminded me of my father, Gurdeep Singh Selvji. He was murdered in a robbery at a Marathon gas station. I believe that my dad was killed because he was wearing a turban, and had a beard; someone who ‘resembled’ a terrorist. It makes me feel a little better to see that through this film the world will begin to understand and learn about Sikhism and other misunderstood religions and cultures. Thank you, Valarie Kaur, you’ve done a lot. Truly a lot.”
Hardeep Singh, 
16-year-old male, Asian (Indian), Sikh, American citizen

“On 9/11/2001, I was in Virginia on a business trip. I had a rental car and drove all the way back to Florida, for the first time in my life, without my turban. I wore a baseball cap, because I felt threatened, for the first time in my life.”
59-year-old male, Indian, Sikh, American citizen

“REALLY, REALLY, REALLY!! moving movie. I thought it was well-made, well-planned and well-executed. My respect goes out to you guys for your work. Your work is bigger than just a movie, it is a change in the way people think. It is a change in people’s lives. I think A LOT of very important points that have been neglected, were very well-presented. Again, my heart and respect goes out to everyone that has made this possible. Keep up the good work and let the fire keep burning.

Nanek Naam Chardee Kalsa, teray bhanay jarbat daa bhalaa!”
Saind Sonlji
, 19-year-old male, human race, Sikh, Akal Purakh Di Faryi

“I hear disappointing things about my khalsa saroop at least once a week — followed by things like ‘Go back to Arabia!’ This hurts because I was born in New York City and am of Italian ancestry. I served in the U.S. Marine Corps in Vietnam for almost two years. I also have a Purple Heart for wounds gotten in combat. I have been harassed by teenagers who haven’t even broken a fingernail for our country, but think that they’re the patriots and I am not…”
62-year-old male, “Gora”, Sikh, American citizen

“The film is beautifully made — masterfully narrated, filmed, and wonderfully organized. As a Sikh, many of these stories have been narrated by others within the community. It was an experience to hear it from the victims themselves. My only hope is that enough people have the opportunity to view the film themselves.”
Rishi Singh Bagga, Esq.
, 24-year-old male, South Asian, Sikh, American citizen

“This film was incredible — I absolutely learned so much. Being a Sikh, I have to say that I am ashamed that I wasn’t aware of the majority of these stories — I am so grateful that this film has opened my eyes to this — THANK YOU so much for working so hard — it’s very touching.

 Valarie — your passion and vision is inspiring and at such a young age, you’ve accomplished so much and made so many people aware of these issues. 

Sharat — the film is beautifully made and very educational.”
27-year-old female, Indian, Sikh, American citizen

“This movie portrayed the hate crimes of not only Sikh Americans, but other racial backgrounds. I felt as though it was not only informative, but a very big eye opener. Being a Sikh, I have personally never experienced any discrimination up til now, but has made me realize how important it is to make sure that our religion is well-represented and understood.”
24-year-old female, Indian, Sikh, American citizen

“Thank you for making a DIFFERENCE!”
27-year-old male, Punjabi, Sikh, American citizen

“Valarie and Sharat,

Congrats again!!! Both films were inspiring, touching and personal. There’s so much I could write about, but there isn’t enough space! So, I am just going to say that both of you have confirmed that positive things can be accomplished by people who are under 30, and lastly, I truly hope one day we can collaborate on a short film or documentary.

Best wishes,”
Yasmine “Yaz” Abellard, 
26-year-old female, Haitian, Christian, American citizen

“You are so young and you’ve already done so much for the world. Bravo! Thank you thank you.”
39-year-old female, Black/White,
Christian/Jewish/Buddhist, etc
 (I talk to God many times every day, but
 my religion right now has absolutely no name),
 American/Jamaican citizen

“Thank you so much for making this movie. We are very proud of your accomplishment and we will always be there to support you.”
46-year-old male, Sikh, American citizen

“I am glad that I watched this movie. I was aware of profiling after September 11 and I was thinking about those that may be false accused. I knew about what was done about Japanese community after Pearl Harbor. I am first-generation immigrant. My experiences with making me feel an outsider are not half as strong as those presented. I will tell people about these movie. It is sending a strong message. I am agree that America is for all of us.”
54-year-old female, White, Catholic, American citizen

“This film festival [Spinning Wheel Film Festival in Miami, Nov. 2006] was the most best thing that ever happened to me. Valarie, you have made the best film I have ever saw. I appreciate that. Thank you very much. And that film was awesome.”
13-year-old male, Indian, Sikh, American citizen

“Well done Valarie! You did an exquisite job. Your community should be very proud of you.”
31-year-old male, Puerto Rican/Italian, Catholic, American citizen

“Very good effort. Excellent work. May Waheguru bless you and more courage and guidance to make a difference in this world and unite the world in love.”
40-year-old female, Indian, Sikh, Indian citizen

“Great movie! Thank you.”
27-year-old female, Hispanic/White, Christian, American citizen

Georgia

“Amazing. A very well done film—you make a person really think and reflect on diversity in America.’”
61-year-old female, white/Lesbian, Unitarian Universalist, U.S. citizen
, Screening at First Existentialist Congregation of Atlanta, 9.11.08

“This is a really good opening to dialog and hopefully education. Respect for others—the Golden Rule.”
60-year-old female, white, Unitarian Universalist, U.S. citizen

“I was working as a paralegal at the NYC office of the EEOC in 7WTC on Sept. 11. This film reflects the values & message I would want others to hear & think about. I’m familiar with the sharp rise in the number of discrimination complaints filed with us after 9/11 from Muslims, Arabs & others seen as either.”
61-year-old female, white, Existentialist/Unitarian Universalist, U.S. citizen (Italian heritage)

“JFK said, ‘He who rides the back of the tiger will wind up inside.’”
66-year-old male, white, Existentialist, U.S. citizen

“Very disturbing—but I’m glad you made it to increase the awareness of us all.”
63-year-old female, white, Unitarian Universalist, U.S. citizen

“Tip of the iceburg [sic] regarding the bigotry, hatred, antiracism that exists in our country & our world—I would like to see various spiritual/peace-building interfaith communities use this film as a starting point for on-going discussion groups among various ethnic/religious group. We must talk to each other deeply!”
67-year-old female, white, Existentialist Unitarian, U.S. citizen

“After seeing the film, the experiences that specifically were shared by the respondents who wore turbans and were targeted brought back flashbacks of experiences of mine in coming out, but in this case the realization of my transgender identity. I was asked to take off things like barets [sic] & make-up by people close to me or to change clothes. The first interviewee, who wore a turban, was asked to take his turban off. He was at first stunned & outraged, but later learned that the perpetrators looked like him, even though he was a Sikh, not a Muslim. I feel deep compassion for Singh, who died as a martyr, from misguided profiling. People have profiled me for coming out, even as a terrorist, in a sense, in extreme cases, a cannibalist. This is what fear can do.”
52-year-old male (transgender), white (trace of Native American), Existentialist, Christian Nonsecular Upbringing, U.S. citizen (Irish, Dutch, French, British, Native American ancestry)

“After 9/11 agencies serving refugees in Metro Atlanta formed a Task Force to address the fears of Muslim refugees and other refugees that they would be attacked. One of the Lost Boys of Sudan was attached in Clarkston, a suburb of Atlanta, Georgia. He was of African descent and a Christian, but was considered a terrorist. After 9/11 the largest mosque in Metro Atlanta and had an open house and invited non-Muslims. Several leaders from my Unitarian Universalist congregation went together to the open house. Today in Atlanta there is an organization called the Faith Alliance of Metro Atlanta that brings together Christians, Jews, Muslims, and other people to build relationships across faith lines. This is important.”
60-year-old female, white, Unitarian Universalist, U.S. citizen

“The ignorance of so many Americans angers and saddens me. On a global level it’s very embarrassing. It is so sad that people are so unfairly and ignorantly targeted. We need much better education on all subjects in the US. The one area that raises controversy for me is the area of ‘racial profiling.’ I am not against it but do understand the anger, fear and frustration of those being ‘profiled.’”
37-year-old female, white, atheist, U.S. citizen

“The stories I have heard in this film were accounts of events that were never reported on the news. I, like most Americans[,] watched the news much more closely in the weeks shortly after 9/11. I didn’t notice any mention of the hate crimes on the evening news, but knew sadly that it would happen. Hopefully, in the future we will learn not to associate the enemy with our own people.”
22-year-old male, white, Christian, U.S. citizen

“This film was beautiful in so many ways. It was something I really needed to see. So often I am frustrated by the blindness and close[-]mindedness of the people in the communities around me. I am so concerned for the future of our country and our world; the world that one day my children will live in. And I would hope that if more people ask questions and listen to real answers, that perhaps we can one day live in a country, in a world, that is more accepting and peaceful, rather than becoming our own terrorists.”
22-year-old female, white, I am spiritual, haven’t found the right religion, U.S. citizen

“Important piece of America’s story. Thank you.”
34-year-old female, white, Unitarian Universalist, U.S. citizen

“The movie was very moving and disturbing. I have worked with people from India and Pakistan who have been treated poorly because of their skin color. They have not shown any animosity, instead believe in educating others to bring about understanding. I have hope for the future.”
53-year-old female, white, Existentialist, U.S. citizen

“Important film. I’m so glad it included a wide variety of those who had been ‘othered’ & subjected to violence of different sorts. I couldn’t help remembering a young Bangladeshi woman in my program at school & how worried many of us were about her after 9/11. She was frightened & shared some of the ways people treated her & said ugly things to her as she went about her daily activities in Atlanta.”
68-year-old female, white, Existentialist, U.S. citizen

“In 1980, I think, during the Iran Hostage Crisis, I worked on a construction site (building the chapel at Candler School of Theology in Emory University). There was one non-American born, a young Iraqi man who worked as a laborer (as I was). He was teased as an Iranian and, I think, hated. He kept protesting that he was not Iranian. One day he was in the portable bathroom. Someone locked him in. Another person (a crane operator) had the bathroom lifted into the air, with him screaming. He was put up on a 2nd floor. He was let out. No one was punished for it that I know.’”
53-year-old male, Caucasian, Christian-Episcopal, United States citizen, 
Emory University
, Atlanta

“I loved the part where the film focused on the injustice done on people of different religion and not just one.”
31-year-old female, Indian, Indian citizen

“Bravo! My second viewing and the story gets richer with each experience. I am looking forward to seeing this film on DVD or in theaters since I have so many people I would like to share the movie with. Thank you to you all.”
44-year-old female, White, Christian-Episcopalian, United States citizen

“Although I have no personal experience with the discrimination I can appreciate the struggles of the Sikh community. As I look back to the history of African Americans in this country I see common threads that connect then with the current issues facing the Sikhs. Your documentary stands as an incredibly inspirational reminder of just how connected we all are.”
22-year-old male, African-American, United States citizen

“Watching the movie was a continuous flow between despair and rage. At the same time the fact that this movie was made inspires hope and further commits my life to interfaith dialogue and education.”
22-year-old female, White, Muslim, United States citizen

“To Valarie and Sonny: Thank you for being brave and taking a leap of faith and making this movie. It was great to hear the untold stories that the US media is not telling.”
25-year-old female, Indian, Indian citizen

“Very interesting. I knew very little about Sikhism before viewing this film.”
21-year-old female, White, Church of Subgenious, United States citizen

“I saw the film a year ago at Illinois Wesleyan at a screening and I remember how moved to action I felt. As I sit here tonight that same feeling is accompanied by bewilderment. What can I do? The problem of hatred is so huge and I feel so small. I want to use my ability to change my lenses and my space, but how?”
22-year-old female, White, United States citizen

“I was one year old when this started. (She drew a picture of herself near a building and in front of a truck/tank on 9/11 and wrote “Help!” next to herself.)”
7-year-old female, Greek, Italian, English and American (White), United States citizen

“This documentary sheds light to a worldwide fixation on separating humanity from race. We all grow up with an angular perception based on our cultural, religion, environment and family. However, in this jungle of diversity we tend to forget the core right of humans to live with peace of mind.”
27-year-old male, Pakistan-American, Muslim, United States citizen

“I thought it was wonderful and heart breaking at the same time. I had heard a lot about hate crimes but it is another thing to see it. I’m glad to see that there are people out there trying to make a difference and making our voices heard. Thank you for all your efforts. Personally, I have been blessed not to have come across any discrimination; I don’t consider special screening at the airport as a problem, albeit it is bothersome.’”
33-year-old female, Muslim-Pakistani, Muslim, Pakistani citizen

“I was in Pakistan when 9/11 happened. I didn’t have a lot of confrontation even when I was traveling back and forth, maybe because I wasn’t looking for people or difference in attitude of people. I wish to educate people about their ignorance and that’s the message I got from the movie. Thanks and God bless.”
33-year-old male, Pakistan, Muslim, United States citizen

“I am so impressed by this film. Thank you so much for making it. I think this film should be shown in every public school in America. I grew up in a small town in south Georgia and can relate to some of the stories. I think that telling these stories is very important.”
21-year-old female, Indian American, Hindu, United States citizen

“This film has been an amazing learning experience for me. Although I was aware of the news reports regarding acts of violence against Sikhs in America, I never knew or had an idea, the extent of the entire Sikhs community’s grief and fear after 9/11. As a Muslim I thought only Muslims were being targeted. Also, thanks to the Film that I’m now very interested in learning about Sikhism. But thanks for America that we’re able to learn about each other, feel each other’s pain, and despite the transgression of some, we also support and stand with one another. Great movie, very inspiring and educational.”
41-year-old male, Black/African, Muslim, Somali and Canadian citizen

“Sak Siri Kaur. Thank you. I recognized the Yogi Bhajan Khalsa Sikh from Arizona, since I practice her Yogi’s yoga. I am Sufi, and Sufis protected the Gold Temple for Sikhs during violence in Punjab states. My Sufi teacher asked us to practice Sikh Kundalini yoga. 1.3 million Iraqis in the less violent areas of Iraq have died since the beginning of the war, and 2.5 million displaced, but we seem to care only about American casualties. Please mention the injuries and deaths our prejudice inflicts outside of America.”
47-year-old female, “White” Greek/Italian, Interfaith Sufi/Muslim who practices Yogi Bhajan (Sikh) yoga, United States citizen

“I thought the film was really wonderful… humorous, emotional, scary. It really evoked emotion I had not felt since viewing news coverage of 9/11. I also really liked the theme of the complexity of identity. What is American identity? Who is included in that identity? These are questions that need to be discussed, and I love that the film adds to these issues and this discussion.”
21-year-old female, White, United States citizen

“I admire the courage and ambition you had to complete this project. As a Jew, my community has always been ‘other’ – for as long as I can remember. That’s what they keep telling us: remember, remember. The project you have completed is a testament to ‘others’ everywhere. Your ability to explore your identity and speak out is remarkable. And the pride of the Sikhs to stand behind their beliefs, wear the turban, and still work to make the US a better place is very moving. I wish you much success in your fight against alienation and prejudice.”
21-year-old female, Jewish, United States citizen

“Thank you to all the persons involved in the making of this film and for your continued courage. You have found a way to articulate a story that I feel is muddled and confused often with myself simply by living in this country and (hopefully) having the presence of mind to continuously question what is being fed to the public as ‘normal.’ I find it appalling that strictly adhering to any belief and identity as an individual can expose the blind fundamentalism that I believe can be the downfall of a compassionate culture.”
24-year-old male, Caucasian, Atheist, United States citizen

“I am from Malaysia, one of many Muslim countries in the world. I have had chances to meet Muslims and Hindus and other relatively minor groups including Sikhs. After the 9/11 attack, I was a little scared that we were going to be attacked because we were in a Muslim country. But I knew that these Muslims who lived with me were different people and they are good Muslims!! But when I walked around the street and found people wearing turbans – Sikhs – I thought they were like terrorists. And even though I knew about Sikhs, for me, they look just like those terrorists I saw on TV. Here, I really want to apologize for my thoughts to your community, I am sorry. I really think you should share your film with people in Asia!!”
21-year-old female, Asian, Presbyterian, South Korean citizen

“Your film was an eye-opening in letting me know the extent to which Sikhs were targeted after 9/11. I feel like more of us need to see it and feel the loss of those who felt the story of retaliation. Good work and good luck in the future.”
65-year-old male, White, United States citizen

Idaho

“It opened my eyes a bit more. Thank you.”
66-year-old male, white, Christian, U.S. citizen
, Screening at Grangeville High School, 9.11.08

“Inspiring – Can we stop maniacs? Yes – time has given us proportionately less of them.”
61-year-old female, white, U.S. citizen

“I wonder if this film is being seen by those who hold blind views of others. Our audience was composed of people who cared.”
57-year-old male, world citizen, no religious affiliation, U.S. citizen

“It is wrong to persecute all of a class because of the action of a few of that nationality.”
80-year-old female, white, Christian, U.S. citizen

“I didn’t truly realize Sikhs were singled out and didn’t hear about many of the hate crimes mentioned – I blame the media on many levels for their lopsided stories.”
40-year-old female, Caucasian, Nazarene Church/Christian, U.S. citizen

“Thank you.”
58-year-old male, WASP, Methodist, U.S. citizen

“As a member of the dominant group, it’s hard for me to walk in the shoes of others who are targeted because of group identity, until their reality is made real to me. Thank you for a good film.”
71-year-old female, Caucasian, Episcopalian, U.S. citizen